As the OP, we are really on the fence about this place. Sort of sounds like a Va. Ocean Lakes. But we like Ocean Lakes. Only thing is, this August will be our first Ocean Lakes trip during the summer months.
For now, we have decided to pass on Cherrystone for a little while. We were debating a trip in May but the water will be far too cold anyway so we're just staying local at a state park we really enjoy. We still may do Cherrystone this year. Possibly July. But they may be booked up by then. Lots of other choices if that's the case.
Thanks to all for your help.