Kelley's Island

bgradert wrote:
Might be more of a hassle than what it is worth. We would like to take the kids to Cedar Point as well. Perhaps we will stay at a state park close to the theme park instead. We can always catch a ride on the ferry to the island for the day as well.

Have you seen the park? You are camping on the lake! Very pretty but only if you plan on spending the bulk of your time enjoying the park and the island. If you are planning multiple trips off the island, yes I would stay somewhere else.