Forum Discussion

Pangaea_Ron's avatar
Pangaea_Ron
Explorer
Sep 29, 2014

Gray tank smells

I've posted about my problem before, and here is what I think is happening.

The gray water vent was installed low into the gray water tank, and did not project through the roof. I have corrected the issue as it projects through the roof plane and have installed a rotating venturi vent, which helps.

I have tried pulling the thru roof vent line upwards (as others have suggested), but it is restrained by a lateral shower drain, and cannot be raised.

When the tank fills (about 2/3 full), the bottom of the vent is submerged below the water level in the tank, and gases find another way to escape, and that is usually through the kitchen sink drains. If I close the drains, and fill the sinks with a bit of water, the smells do not occur. The "P" trap below the sinks does not seem adequate to prevent the smells. I have replaced the under-counter vent frequently.

I am considering putting a "T" in the vertical line to the under-counter vent and running a vent line downwards through the floor level to the exterior below the chassis. It's not a perfect solution. but running a vent line to the exterior is not possible through the roof or wall. It seems like the gasses should follow that route rather than upwards through the sink drains.

Dropping the tank to investigate seems like a formidable task.

Any thoughts?
  • Seems to me you would need to make a longer/deeper P trap and not just lower the thing. The water level would stay the same in your idea, unless I have the wrong picture in my mind. Just lowering the whole thing down from where it is now will not do a thing except give you a longer drain to clean stuff out of. Water always seeks it's own level.
    Barney
  • I took a plumber friend to lunch yesterday and he suggested something to try.

    He said to remove the threaded under-counter vent and replace it with threaded reducing bushings until I can get a 3/4" bayonet hose fitting to fit. Then attach a 3/4" hose that extends to the exterior.

    It should allow gray tank smells to get to the exterior, and would also prevent a vacuum from forming while draining the kitchen sink(s).

    This seems like the easiest approach, which I will try this weekend.
  • If your P-traps dry out from evaporation,
    the lack of water in them will allow
    gas/odor to pass.
  • Oldme

    That's a good thought. At home I regularly add water to P-traps of un-used plumbing fixtures to avoid smells passing through dry P-traps.

    Unfortunately dry P-traps are not my issue, the build up of pressure (or sloshing) can overwhelm water in the P-traps, when the roof vent is blocked.

About DIY Maintenance

RV projects you can tackle on your own with a few friendly pointers.4,351 PostsLatest Activity: Jan 18, 2025