Grand Design to Forest River XLR......need advice....

Oddly though, I prefer the old white look with colored graphics. But that's just me. My F350 is also the Ingot Metallic and of course, what ever I get HAS to match the truck. :B

As for the OP. I don't have either toy hauler you mentioned. But either one would be an awesome choice in my opinion. If the dear wife likes the XLR better and you can swing it, I can't imagine you'd be unhappy with that move.