Bought a Cameo June 2011. Really like the way the trailer is put together. Very few problems. I guess the biggest we had to change out water pump and that is not Cameo's problem. Shurflow covered it. Best trailer we ever owned. Thus saying I do agree with the top poster if you could find a Carriage product still sitting on someones lot go for it. I have looked at the Lifestyle. It is very close to the Cameo since it is made by past Cameo employees, and Carriage specs. It is a beautiful trailer. Don't know much about Redwood. We stayed in a very large camp ground in Colorado all summer. I think I saw one Redwood comes through. I did see quite a few Carriages.