Forum Discussion

Caseyjones955's avatar
Caseyjones955
Explorer
Jul 14, 2013

Towing with Auto vs. Manual opinions. Looking for a TV

Greetings folks!

New to RVing, started out looking for an A but after receiving wisdom of the experienced on this board I decided on a 5th wheel setup. Q regarding tow vehicles.

I am decided on a 99-03 F250/F350 7.3 Power Stroke 4 door, 2 or 4wd, preferably not with dual rears. 30-ish foot 5th and probably with a 3300lb Samurai Dingy toad (if it fits and feels reasonably safe).


Auto: wont last as long under hard towing, getting less MPG, easier to tow?

Manual: Reliable, long lasting, better MPG, more of a chore to drive?

Hoping for some thoughts from those that have used both, wondering what sort of MPG and longevity/reliability advantage I may realize with a manual. I would like an auto but putting priority on reliability, longevity and relative economy.

Thanks
Tony

42 Replies

Show More
  • mrbunzo's avatar
    mrbunzo
    Explorer
    Jul 14, 2013
    Well CJ, her is my take on that upcoming argument. Modern automatics are(1) equal to or exceed mileage from a manual, look at the load and mileage ratings between the two from the manufacturers. Also, some diesels aren't available with a manual trans. (2)I think this would lead one to believe they are as reliable, and I know from personal experience that they take a lot of the driving load off the operator.

    Now we can wait for the discussion to why whatever the have is better, lookout for some low level shouting and arm waving.
  • netjam's avatar
    netjam
    Explorer
    Jul 14, 2013
    Doubt if you will come across too many manual transmissions. I suspect, if you find the tow vehicle you want, you'll have to take the transmission it comes with.

About Fifth Wheel Group

19,024 PostsLatest Activity: Oct 20, 2024