Mvpmich wrote:
TNGW1500SE wrote:
I don't see how the pipe would cause an odor even if it is "to far down" in the tank. Does the odor come from the toilet of could it be from the sink? Some RV's a plumbed so the bath sink goes into the black tank. Check for a vent under the bath sink
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f945f/f945fb2ecc91e2eb0295c21bc650cb824214b628" alt=""
If the vent pipe is too far down in the tank it could be below the fluid line and therefore prevents air from escaping. The problem is probably twofold, 1) the tank needs to be flushed and cleaned and possibly sanitized to rid any long standing or built up materials and 2) better exhausting from the vent stack.
I had similar problems after I dumping and thought the tank was empty and clean only to find residual waste as well as back drafting while driving. I installed a Camco Cyclone swivel cover on the vent stack that allows the wind to suck out the odor either while driving or stationery. There are other types including the DIY "t" mentioned that will give you the same results.
He's talking about the pipe from the toilet to the tank being to far down.
Shouldn't the toilet seal in all the odor? It does on mine. If I wanted to smell the black tank, I'd have to go on the roof.
PS: I have no plans to do so ;)