AzLADY: Same thing for me with the Good Sam directory. One park i stayed at got a 4.4.4. MY opinion was much much much higher. Another got a 8.8.8. In MY opinion, it should have gotten a 4.4.4.. In that park, the sewer hookup was SIDEWAYS...used quite a bit of duct tape on that one.......in fact, at the end of this cross-country trip I complained to Good Sam about their ratings (with references to these two particular parks)....never got a reply.
Possible, these cg are not reviewed every year...maybe more than one year. How many reviewers can there possibly be vs all the parks out there?
Generally, however, this directory is good. The quality of parks, generally do not change much year to year...but exceptions abound...and the ratings might even depend on who takes who to dinner. (sarcasm)