Toad or No Toad ?- Grand Canyon road trip in a 23' class A

We ditched our toad years ago and have no regrets. We get around just fine in our Winnebago Navion, which is almost 26 feet long. We have gone sightseeing through national parks with no problems, and finding parking has always been easy. Same thing traveling in narrow and congested streets in San Francisco, CA and Old Quebec City in Canada. I would only recommend renting a car if you're planning on staying put in one place for extended periods.