Same "problem" here. Front analog TV works, bedroom analog TV doesn't. The older TVs must have that digital to analog converter box.
My front TV has one. No problem. The bedroom TV does not. So...anytime I must use the antenna, no bedroom TV. I DO happen to have another converter box...but the bedroom TV is simply not that important to us. So it sits. BTW, I haven't used my antenna in about 2 -3 years. The cgs' I stop at all have cable.
However...cable and sat come in just fine both TVs.. I will be converting to flat screen (read; digital) TVs in the near future.