Forum Discussion

RoyBell's avatar
RoyBell
Explorer
Aug 04, 2016

good substitute for Weber 22"?

I am getting tired of lugging the kettle around when camping. It's just not made easy to move. I tried the smokey joe in the past, but it's just too small and I don't like how it cooks. I see they have a jumbo joe now. I have carried my 18" on occasion but felt it was small and not much different than just carrying the 22".

I like charcoal but willing to do gas while camping for the convenience. Lot of times we pull into the camp site late and the kids are hungry and the 20-30 minute to heat the coals forces everyone to eat way late.

My requirements are a grill large enough to grill for 6 people. Sometimes it's just 2 of us, other times 4, other times 6 or more. The 22" seems perfect for when we make potatoes and burgers for everyone as there's enough room for all of it.

We will also make pizzas sometimes and I can fit 2 x boboli pizzas on the 22"

According to my highschool math, the 22" kettle has a surface cooking area of 380 square inches. The 14" models are 153" which is fine for 2 people, but that's it. The 18" is 254 square inches which I feel is small, but can make due. We will likely have to give up the pizzas or just make one at a time. The other issue with the smaller grills is they are tabletop which I hate. Some CG don't have picnic tables and I hate cooking on tables in general because they get all nasty.

Looking at the gas grills, it appears everyone here loves the weber version. I am a bit skeptical because of the cost and weight of these suckers. Sounds like the Colemans are junk. I saw a Zippo brand one on Amazon that looks like a nice setup, but I can't see zippo making a good grill, despite the raving reviews on Amazon.

Looking for some input. Whats everyone lug around easily for a family of up to 6 people? Convert to gas for ease of packing? Stick with charcoal and make due with the 18" version? One benefit the gas versions is leaving the charcoal bin at home and not having to deal with a hot grill. One less thing to worry about and throw in the truck is always good. The negative is they are way expensive. Thoughts?

15 Replies

  • I don't really get the grill size to # of people comparison. I think I read the q1200 claims to feed 8 people? Do they make that claim because you can fit eight small hamburger patties on the grill, or eight small bratwurst?

    On the q1200, cooking for myself, I can fit one cowboy / tomahawk steak on the grill, along with an ear of corn and a big piece of broccoli. The outer few inches of grill surface aren't usable, since the lid will contact any food near the edge, and that's gross.

    On the 22.5, I can fit six half racks of ribs, standing on edge, with about half the grill surface "off" the coals. I once direct grilled six chicken breast and it was crowded, there was certainly no room left over for cooking some veggies, or garlic bread.

    So, I'm not a good judge of using grill space efficiently I guess!
  • GordonThree wrote:
    Stick with the 22! Is the 18 really going to be that much lighter?

    I use a one touch gold 22.5 for summer camping, and the q1200 for winter camping. the q1200 although smaller, weighs more, but being propane, it's very fast to cook on, which is good when it's freezing cold outside.

    I leave my q1200 on the Weber cart all the time, the cart is mostly cheap plastic, and doesn't add much weight to the already heavy grill.

    Have you considered going minimalist, and getting a camp fire cooking tripod? Then you just need the main grate from 22, and the tripod.


    The 18" would be the jumbo joe model, which should fit in a rubbermaid bin with the chimney. Right now the 22" barely fits and I have to put it sideways. Then I have to take the legs off when traveling and they dont store anywhere. I have an 18" that someone was throwing out that was in good shape. I got a new grate for it and it's fine, but same issue with the legs and trying to move transport it.

    I have too many grills already. 2x22s, 1x18, 1x 14"smokey joe. I may give the 18" another run next time and see if I can make due with the small cooking area. Only issue is you can't cook indirect on the smaller grills. I will have to figure out how to grill with coals under the meat.

    What model Q is large enough for 6 people? Is the single burner going to be an issue coming from charcoal where I can make hot spots and cool spots for different food?
  • Stick with the 22! Is the 18 really going to be that much lighter?

    I use a one touch gold 22.5 for summer camping, and the q1200 for winter camping. the q1200 although smaller, weighs more, but being propane, it's very fast to cook on, which is good when it's freezing cold outside.

    I leave my q1200 on the Weber cart all the time, the cart is mostly cheap plastic, and doesn't add much weight to the already heavy grill.

    Have you considered going minimalist, and getting a camp fire cooking tripod? Then you just need the main grate from 22, and the tripod.