Forum Discussion

Jerrybo66's avatar
Jerrybo66
Explorer
Oct 14, 2015

Trained VS taught ?

We rescued our Rottie about nine months ago and found she's about the most stubborn dog we've had. The balance, I'm a pig-headed old kraut myself. We understand each other just fine. My thought. I got some books from the library for dog training. I read less than half. There is no way I'd want a dog commercially "trained" but without the ability to think. My observation. From the part of the book I read, the dog was "trained" to act as a robot without reasonable thought of what they were to do. I think this is cruel. My thought. I understand the robotic commands for trail dogs where money is the subject but I think the word "train" has no place in our pets. I teach her that she's not to leave the property. I tell her she's not to eat the Pit Bull's food. I "teach" her other commands I want her to know but she has to do them willing. Not automatically. If some ****** breaks into my home before I can react I want her to be able to figure out the circumstance by herself without relying on a robotic training. I guess this is a moot subject but the other day I was giving her hell for eating the other dogs food. After a minute or so she bared her teeth to me. How do you correct a dog while laughing. Her thought. "ok I'm bad, get over it". A family pet, not programed for profit has to be able to express it's self. I have to continue to learn to understand.. This rescue girl is a learning gem..
OK. I admit.. I don't know what is involved in commercial training....... Flame away..

21 Replies

  • I agree with you on robot dogs. They're often the product of training methods endorsed by Cesar Milan and the like. The term most trainers use for those dogs is "shut down." They're so afraid of making a mistake that they won't do ANYTHING to risk a correction. They've totally shut down any natural curiosity/personality/playfulness.

    It's very sad.

    Awhile back someone posted a video of a man walking a pack of GSDs w/o a leash, as if that was a good thing. Every single one of those dogs cringed or flinched a tiny bit every time they glanced at the man (some obviously did everything they could to avoid looking at him). Some of it was subtle, you had to watch very closely and know what you were looking for to notice it. I wish I had brain bleach to get that video out of my mind.