Forum Discussion

  • Almost every time someone here mentions 'HD' antenna, they are corrected, and rightly so that there is no such thing. An antenna is an antenna. Period...
  • The article is partially correct. There is no such thing as a HD antenna but an ant. that is specifically designed for improved UHF reception will work better for HD TV than one that was designed for VHF - like the venerable bat-wing. That's why antennas like the Jack pick up a lot more stations.
  • My friends' HD channels are great. It's just the non-HD channels (like 2,4,8,10,12) that seem worse than my own old TV.
  • If you can't see improvement in an old analog set versus a good brand of High Definition Television your eyesight may be bad.

    Also; your friends may not have used the correct cables, or set up the set properly to actual get a high-definition signal.

    If you are happy with what you have there is no reason for you to spend money to change things.
  • I guess I'm in kindergarten then, because I had been wondering why the often discussed Jack antenna, for example, labels itself as an HDTV Antenna and if I can use it with my old analog TV. On my old motorhome I did get a Jack installed so I found out that the answer is yes.

    Thank you for posting that link, HappyKayakers.

    MNtundraRet, since you seem to know lots about electronics, maybe you can answer a question for me. I haven't bought a new TV (LED/LCD HD) for either my motorhome or house because I don't spend enough time at home to buy HD channels from my Cable company, and RV parks with Cable generally do not offer HD channels. When I see HD TVs at my friends' houses, the regular old channels (non-HD) look worse on their TVs than on my old analog TV. Why?

    Because of this, I hesitate to buy a new TV.

    (Sorry to take this thread on a tangent, but it seemed a good opportunity for my inquiry.)
  • Now that you pointed out that well known fact (kindergarten lesson), we have to deal with the real world.

    The cheapest old fashion indoor antennas are good for about a 10 to 15 mile range.

    I get up to 120 mile range (daytime) and 150+ miles after dark for my high-definition television signals. I use a Winegard III with Wingman and a second in-line adjustable amplifier (R.S. 15-2505 about $33.)

    You can check my past replies to posts on the subject and "Over the air TV revisited".
  • It's no different than the unscrupulous dealers who were selling color antennas in the mid '50s.

About RV Must Haves

Have a product you cannot live without? Share it with the community!8,793 PostsLatest Activity: Feb 08, 2025