Forum Discussion

wtmtnhiker's avatar
wtmtnhiker
Explorer
Oct 05, 2013

Craigslist

When you post something on Craigslist for sale and someone emails you with a long return address similar to 9591d9f4935398aa0d3f619dd4b4e0f@reply.craigslist.org how do they do that? Do they have a craigslist acct? Is it spam? Should I reply to it?
  • It is the typical return email address that you will see in the reply to section of your listing. Not necessarily a scam at all. It keeps the emails private. Use your own discretion as to the honesty of the correspondence. Ask for a phone number in your reply and carry on the conversation in that manner.
  • BuckBarker wrote:
    It is the typical return email address that you will see in the reply to section of your listing. Not necessarily a scam at all. It keeps the emails private. Use your own discretion as to the honesty of the correspondence. Ask for a phone number in your reply and carry on the conversation in that manner.

    If I were a potential buyer how would I get an address like that? I haven't seen anything on craigslist about it. I understand about the anonymous address of the seller but not the potential buyer.
  • When the buyer replies to the seller's craigslist account, he his assigned an e-mail of his own (that long e-mail).
    If I'm really interested in something, I'll usually copy/paste their e-mail to my own e-mail (gmail), and send it....I think it makes me a bit more legit:)
    But, what you are seeing is OK.
  • PapPappy wrote:
    When the buyer replies to the seller's craigslist account, he his assigned an e-mail of his own (that long e-mail).
    If I'm really interested in something, I'll usually copy/paste their e-mail to my own e-mail (gmail), and send it....I think it makes me a bit more legit:)
    But, what you are seeing is OK.

    Thanks for the info. Thanks to all for the replies :)
  • I have used craigslist a lot to both buy and sell. The only anonymous email I have ever seen is for the seller. So I am a little confused regarding these responses that state it is normal. I have even checked with craigslist and according to them when you reply to a post your email shows they do not assign an anonymous reply email.

    Q: How do anonymous craigslist addresses (similar to abcde-1234567890@sale.craigslist.org) work?

    A: Posters to craigslist can choose to use a temporary craigslist address to receive responses. As long as the post is still active, craigslist will relay any messages sent to the temporary address to the poster's actual email address.

    Note: When you reply to a post, your email address will be visible to the recipient. If you prefer to remain anonymous, consider using an email address that does not contain your name or other identifying information.
  • shakyjay wrote:
    I have used craigslist a lot to both buy and sell. The only anonymous email I have ever seen is for the seller. So I am a little confused regarding these responses that state it is normal. I have even checked with craigslist and according to them when you reply to a post your email shows they do not assign an anonymous reply email.

    Q: How do anonymous craigslist addresses (similar to abcde-1234567890@sale.craigslist.org) work?

    A: Posters to craigslist can choose to use a temporary craigslist address to receive responses. As long as the post is still active, craigslist will relay any messages sent to the temporary address to the poster's actual email address.

    Note: When you reply to a post, your email address will be visible to the recipient. If you prefer to remain anonymous, consider using an email address that does not contain your name or other identifying information.

    I'm getting these anonymous email addresses with responses to my for sale ad.
  • the email comes thru craiglist
    the sender does not have your email address, Unless you specifially included it inside your listing
    Craigslist uses your email address provided to your acct to send/fwd tne email generated by the 'interested party' when they clicked on the link in the listing

    the interested party should have supplied you with valid contact info inside their msg to you
    either a ph number or a emaild address

    ignore anything that does not have valid contact info in the msg
  • wtmtnhiker wrote:

    I'm getting these anonymous email addresses with responses to my for sale ad.

    Both the Craigslist lister(seller) and buyer are assigned anonymous Craigslist email addresses through email-relay. So not just the seller. This is supposedly to reduce Spam and Scam replies which are quite common when listing with Craigslist.

    This system is also designed to make it easier to block spammers by clicking the flag link, which will block in theory an email recipient from sending further emails. However, its only partially effective at best.

    First, all a spammer has to do is use a different email address, and will get through. Worse, it may be possible to extract your real email address from the email headers itself. Possibly allowing a savvy spammer to continue to email you directly.

    In general, I would not reply to any email that simply states "Is it still available?" or "I want to buy it?" as these are likely from scammers. In fact, I've checked the sending IP address in the email headers from these types of replies, and many time discovered them to originate from overseas. Clearly, a scam.

    A better approach may be to just require a phone no contact, or place a phone no in your ad yourself. You can get a free Google Voice phone no if you do not want to give out your own. It will forward all calls to your real phone. I do this will all my ads. You also tend to get real buyers more often this way.

    BTW, I believe Craigslist will filter out email address and phone numbers placed in listing. They do this to protect your privacy. However, you can easily get around this by using a graphic image(jpeg, gif, or png) of your phone no instead.
  • All I can say is the information I posted is directly from Craigslist. I have also replied to some of my own ads to see if they assign an anonymous email and they don't.

About RV Must Haves

Have a product you cannot live without? Share it with the community!8,793 PostsLatest Activity: Aug 22, 2023