Forum Discussion

garyhaupt's avatar
garyhaupt
Explorer
Aug 21, 2014

A new two-stage furnace?

Over in the C Forum, there is a question posed about what to order on a new rig. One of the suggestions was for a two-stage propane furnace. I see that Atwood makes one for RV's (http://www.atwoodmobile.com/furnaces/excalibur-8500-iv-series.asp. The Excalibur models. Does anyone have one of these and if so....yes/no? I am thinking of being able to lower the power consumption? And with a two stage, maybe be rid of that off and on thing, but have a more constant low heat output, low noise fan, too.

Any thoughts?



Gary Haupt
  • Atwood is no longer producing the two stage furnaces. The RV manufacturers didn't want to spend the extra $, and chose instead to continue with what they have been using. I have contacted Stag, a supplier and they have some and now I am on the hunt for an RV dealer in Montana or Wyoming, to see what the actual costs would be. ( I am off to Mt and Wy in the next couple weeks, for three weeks.)

    If anyone wants to suggest a good service centre in either Mt or Wy., I am all eyes...


    Gary Haupt
  • They are excellent. If the temp is way off where you have it set it will come on on high speed until it is within a couple degrees of where you have it set. Then it will drop to half speed and half burn. Quieter than the hydronic heat systems. Constant even quiet heat. . An excellent drop in replacement for other Atwood furnaces. I've sold a few RV's with them and when my Atwoods die I'll replace them with these.

    Good luck.
  • Gary, I think Golden's point is that he would rather have a furnace come on full force with maximum heat output for a shorter period of time, thus reducing the draw on his battery as the fan comes on. His thinking, I believe, is that a lower stage would need to cycle more often.
  • Yeah, Golden..all mine is boondocking too..never campgrounds, although for the next three weeks, that is going to change, anyway..back to the furnace...so, you don't think that a two stage would keep your unit warm? I am presuming that the temp would fall back, but perhaps not rapidly? I gotta call Atwood.


    Gary Haupt
  • The two stage furnace was std eqpt in my former Lance 981Max TC. I loved it and wish I had it in this TT.
  • I do a lot of boondocking, and as such most of the time that the furnace is running is using precious battery power. And it is noisy. I would rather have a higher heat output for a very few minutes, then shut it off.

    When not boondocking, I am in a campground with hookups, and then use a electric heater, and don't hear that fan at all!

    Also when boondocking, my Olympic 6000 Btu catalytic heater is on if it is below 45F outside, and I don't cycle the furnace much, until below 25F outside.

    So the two stage will not do me any good at all.

    Fred.

About RV Tips & Tricks

Looking for advice before your next adventure? Look no further.25,113 PostsLatest Activity: Feb 22, 2025