I have had them both and there is very little difference in them. Dependability is equal on reception. I have dish now because they will give me RFD-TV in my line up and I cannot be with out RFD-TV. A big difference I find is the customer service. I got the run around with Direct, but Dish will be there the next day if not sooner. I have worn out two DVRs now, but I use them for all programs except the national news. I hate commercials, so the DVR really gets a work out. They run "hot" so eventually you will have problems. Dish just sends some out to replace it and check your dish aim.