Jeep or CRV - the search for a toad continues
Narrowing down the search for a new toad that we can tow 4 down. DW's current Civic requires a dolly and it's a pain. So we drove the CRV and frankly she's not crazy about it. It's a great toad based ...
Forum Discussion
OP here, I think we have decided on the CRV. The Jeep is a fine vehicle and we rented one on our last trip to FL. I was surprised at the road manners, It really felt more like an SUV. But a few things bothered me. Side impact ratings are not as good. To be expected when you can take the doors off - I get it. But with a child this is a concern for me. Secondly, it had 2 leaks. This was a brand new jeep mind you with only 1500 miles. Top was secure but at each side near the front at the top of the door, it leaked during a hard rain. Then there is the price. This is apples and oranges when comparing the Unlimited to a CRV. I can get a 2012 CRV for $16-18k but a comparably priced Unlimited will likley be a 2007 with 60k - 100k miles. Jeeps are just too expensive for what you get. I understand it's a "jeep" thing. They hold their value this is true. But I have to be frugal and responsable especially when this will act as a daily driver too. And lastly there is no way my Mother in Law can get into it. We care for my Wife's mother who has had a stroke and that often means taking her to appoinments etc. She simply would not be able to get into it short of lifting her up. Not doing that. I actually found the Unlimited cumbersome to get into myself. The running boards are too high and close to the door sill. It really made no sense. I mean why have them at all? They just got in the way. I hit my shins twice, and when I didn't, standing on the running boards puts you too high and then it feels like I am dropping down into a corvette. I am sure there is a reason for it, I didn't like it. Anyway, I liked the Jeep overall, I really did. I envisioned top down trips with the wind in my hair etc etc. But I have to be practical. If I could afford both I would. The CRV is a far more practical vehicle, especially as a daily driver. it may not be an offroad vehicle but we don't camp anywhere where we need or want to go off-road. The CRV's cost of ownership is much less than the Jeep. It may not be as fun but the CRV is the clear winner for our needs and budget. Thanks to all your input.
