JaxDad wrote:
Turtle n Peeps wrote:
E free gas will give you about 4 to 5% difference in mileage.
If anybody tells you appreciably more their math is wrong or their testing is flawed.
E gas will always give you more power because of the O2 and cooling effect it give your engine.
If you only drive your vehicle in a laboratory that MIGHT be true, however in the real world we have to deal with water-entrainment, sensors thrown off by water, phase separation and the further increased inefficiencies after phase separation occurs.
Even the EPA has acknowledged that E10 gasoline can (at 70 deg. F.) hold 50 times the water in solution than E0 gasoline can. At just 0.5% water-entrainment phase separation begins.
Bottom line, you cannot lose just 4% or 5% in mileage when you have nearly that much water in your tank.
Sure you can.
Water has 0 calories in it. If you have 0 calories in water and you have 1/2 percent water in your fuel you will lose 1/2 percent in mileage. The math really is that simple. On a side note, very small amounts of water going through an engine is not a huge problem anyway. In fact, it can give some help with octane requirements. Ever hear of water injection? Although I don't necessarily want water in my fuel, water injection and it's affects are a very good thing.
Another side benefit of having small amounts of alkie in your gasoline is water. If you have pure gasoline and you pick up a few ounces of water that water will always be separate from the gasoline and if sucked into your fuel system you will be dead on the road. Not so with E fuel. With E10 it will be incorporated with the gasoline and be run through the fuel system and burned in the engine without any problems.
As far as mileage goes: California has had E10 since the mid 80's. I had a friend that insisted he lost more than 10% mileage when it came out way back when. I asked him what happened to the BTU's of the alkie? All I got was a blank stare. :R My point to him was when you put 10% ethanol in gasoline you don't have 10% less BTU's or 10% less mileage because the BTU's in the alkie just does not disappear.
Phase separation has never been a problem for me (or anybody else that I can tell). I have never heard any huge talk about it on the forums that I go on. In fact, phase separation is a non issue unless you live in - degree weather and keep your gas in your tank for a VERY long time. A lot of racers use E85 and if it was a problem everybody would know about it.
Bottom line is I'm not a fan of E fuels at all. But they are here to stay whether you or me or anybody else likes them or not. And at 10% they do a great job of cleaning up our air. So that's not a bad deal at all IMHO.
Three Ethanol Myths Clarified.