I have one question of the O/P
You said the OEM batteries looked more like "Starting Batteries than Deep Cycle"
Since the only visible difference is the battery model number .. How can that be?
Now I do understand that most starting batteries are Valve Regulated SLA batteries (Maintenance free) including all AGMs.. And most are in a black rectangular "Box" though other colors are possible.
And MOST deep cycles today are GC-2 Flooded wet (With caps so you can add distilled) But I am old enough to remember flooded wet cell starting batteries.
That said the most common 12 volt "Deep Cycle" is really a Marine Starting battery with lip service to deep cycle. you can safely take it down to around 75% as opposed to 80 for Starting and 50 for True DEEP CYCLE
ANd you can get Valve Regulated SLA DEEP CYCLES as well. So the appearance is identical.