I'm watching this thread as I put a set on my TH three months ago, I was worried as I had trouble in the past with Carlisle tires before (about 8 years ago).
At the time of looking for new tires for the TH, this was the only one I could find with the load rating I needed, besides waiting 1.5 weeks and paying for shipping fees for Maxxis.
I really can't contest to the Carlisle tires as I only been out one time since they were put on, and we only travel about 2000miles per year with our TH.