Forum Discussion
Huntindog
May 27, 2016Explorer
fj12ryder wrote:Huntindog wrote:I've worked around machinery for 40 years that depended on grease and oil seals to keep lubricants where they belong. And as long as the seal isn't damaged, it actually will pretty much last forever. I've seen them last long enough for that rubber coated spring seal lip wear a groove in a 4 inch diameter steel shaft.fj12ryder wrote:What part is ridiculous?Huntindog wrote:Okay, that's not the most ridiculous thing I've ever read, but it's pretty darned close.
The first big problem here is that there are only two kinds of grease seals. Those that leak, and those that will leak.
That's right. There has never been a grease seal made that won't fail at some point.
The next problem here is that WHEN a grease seal in the easy lube system fails..... It is unseen. It is most always discovered after the damage is done.
So for those of you that are giving good reports on using this system... I am happy for you now.
But at some point your seals WILL fail too. It could be next week, next year or the year after. For all you know, they may have failed now.:E
The part about all seals failing at some point? Surely you don't believe that they will last forever.
The part about the grease getting on the brakes when they fail? That is pretty much indisputable unless you have disk brakes.
How do you think they keep oil, under pressure I might add, in engines? They use oil seals and those seals last hundreds of thousands of miles. When was the last time you pulled the engine of your car apart to replace the seals? Or pulled the wheel bearings off your car for failed grease seals? Or pulled the differential for leaking oil seals?
Grease seals and oil seals work the same way. So yeah, yours was a pretty ridiculous statement.
Ummmm. Replacing a engine rear main seal is pretty common. I have done a few on my own autos.. Iv'e done a few axle pinion seals and axle shaft seals too.
I've also seen quite a few wheel bearing seals that failed.
But I have built quite a few motors, transfer cases, trannys and differentials.... So I DO know what I am talking about.
But in most all of the cases I just listed, a failed seal is mostly an annoyance. The particular part just oozes or leaks fluid without causing any harm other than a spot on the driveway.... Not rear main with a stick shift though... That oil gets on the clutch.
Our TT wheel bearing grease will end up on the brakes.
About Technical Issues
Having RV issues? Connect with others who have been in your shoes.24,188 PostsLatest Activity: Jan 17, 2025