I have the recirculating thetford.  I am getting ready to replace mine for the 3rd time.  Seems they last 40-50 openings and closings over 4 years before the blade catches the seal edge & bends it back.  Seems like a poor design.  And in my B I have to get under the van to unbolt the through floor bolts to remove the toilet.  A 2 day job & too much effort.  I can remove the top easily.  In the future I'll do this after emptying and directly apply some lubricant several times a year.  Thetford has their own product.  
I will try that hot water fix soon first.  Hope the tip works.