Forum Discussion

bob8687's avatar
bob8687
Explorer
Aug 19, 2013

Surge Guard

Getting ready to order our first fiver and am looking at various accessories etc. I realize the importance of a surge guard and am wondering if hard mounted or portable is best. Seems cost wise, security etc. would have me wanting a permanent mounted one-- am I missing something here?
Thanks!
Bob
  • We have a portable 50amp Surge Guard and I like the idea of having it test the campground power before I ever have our MH connected.

    On the one occasion we had a 50amp leg missing at a campground it was easy to show the local "tech" guy they had a problem and I didnt connect until he had it repaired.
  • You should be looking for and energy management system, EMS. The coverage of these devices far exceeds simple "surge protection". The measure of the surge protection capability of a device is calibrated in joules. The higher the joule rating the higher the capability of the device to protect against an electrical surge. The EMS devices provide substantially more protection than a simple surge protection device. An argument for hard wired is the capability of a remote display, ie. the ability to monitor the device from within the rig. The hard wired device is much safer as regards the possibility that the portable device may be stolen however, that issue doesn't seem to be as big a problem in reality as it is in the fear of theft. It is likely that a review here regarding the selection of an EMS device is very likely to indicate a strong preference for the Progressive Industries products. Furthermore is also appears that PI has a far better track record as regards customer service and device support. The EMS devices are relatively expensive however, replacing a "bunch" of electronics on-board is clearly far more costly than the EMS device. A device that is simply a volt metre will tell you when the disaster occurred, assuming you are looking at the "thing" when the spike hit. A voltmetre simply measures current, it gives you absolutely NO protection from the damage that an electrical surge may cause. The moral of the story is again, you get what you pay for. Thinking a $10 voltmetre can appropriately and adequately replace a much more expensive EMS device is a fools folly.
  • My 50 amp is permanently mounted in the converter department. A permanent mount is one less thing to set up and take down if you move a lot.

    Bill
  • Personal choice. I had my Progressive Industry EMS unit internally mounted. Display is mounted in cabinet with the rest of my tank levels and switches. In hind sight I probably should have had it mounted somewhere more accessible. I have to pull the wall in my basement to get to mine but you really don't have to do much with it.

About Technical Issues

Having RV issues? Connect with others who have been in your shoes.24,210 PostsLatest Activity: Mar 02, 2025