GrodymanExplorerOct 06, 2013Water Heater Broke?One of kids accidentally turned water heater on and I got weird smell and soot from the burner. I have not experienced this before. Any clues?Gman
6 RepliesReplies sorted by NewestRJsfishinExplorerOct 07, 2013Just answer the question !If it don't work, its broke !ScottGNomadOct 07, 2013Was there water in it? if not then and the electric portion was energized then the heater element is burned out.old_guyExplorerOct 07, 2013sounds like a bug got in there and blocked the tube and it back fired. is there a soot mark on the out side of the heater?PapPappyExplorerOct 06, 2013Was it drained?Weird smell.....what does it smell like?And as asked above...is is still working? I'd take the cover off the outside, and check things out....anything obvious?Good Luck:)Old-BiscuitExplorer IIIOct 06, 2013Has it been awhile since being used?Spider webs/critter nests etc. inside combustion chamber will cause sooting and smell funny.So....does it work now.IF not be more specific on what it is doing and not doing.Also Brand/Model really helpspugslyyyExplorerOct 06, 2013Does it work now? Is the thermal cutoff burned? Atwood heater? gas/electric or just gas? Does it work in electric but not gas?
ScottGNomadOct 07, 2013Was there water in it? if not then and the electric portion was energized then the heater element is burned out.
old_guyExplorerOct 07, 2013sounds like a bug got in there and blocked the tube and it back fired. is there a soot mark on the out side of the heater?
PapPappyExplorerOct 06, 2013Was it drained?Weird smell.....what does it smell like?And as asked above...is is still working? I'd take the cover off the outside, and check things out....anything obvious?Good Luck:)
Old-BiscuitExplorer IIIOct 06, 2013Has it been awhile since being used?Spider webs/critter nests etc. inside combustion chamber will cause sooting and smell funny.So....does it work now.IF not be more specific on what it is doing and not doing.Also Brand/Model really helps
pugslyyyExplorerOct 06, 2013Does it work now? Is the thermal cutoff burned? Atwood heater? gas/electric or just gas? Does it work in electric but not gas?
About Technical IssuesHaving RV issues? Connect with others who have been in your shoes.24,369 PostsLatest Activity: Mar 12, 2026
Related ContentAtwood water heater problemWater Heater Replacement RecommendationsWater Heater Leak on start up.Suburban SW12DEL Water Heater On/OFF switch melts???Tankless water heater