Lantley wrote:
Martyn wrote:
I stand by what I said, because it is true. If it doesn’t conform to accepted ‘standards’ that is nothing to do with me. My 2019 hemi gets about the same MPG towing my 5er as my old 2004 Cummins. I was surprised when it worked out that way, but it did.
Comparing a modern vehicle to a 15 year old vehicle has little value.
A lot of innovation occurs in 15 years.
Any 2019 vehicle is superior to its 2004 version.
Not sure why you’d say there’s little value in the comparison. Of course there’s advancements. But apple to apples the mpg comparison is valid. And 10mpg towing a 10k 5ver with a 3rd Gen Cummins is realistic and within range of what is expected. However at the same speeds and conditions one would expect to get max fuel mileage like Martyn is claiming out of the new Hemi, the old Cummins would do better than 10. More like 13. Based on my 200k miles of ownership of a 3rd Gen Dodge diesel.
The towing mileage is not near as laughable as the bobtail mpg claims.
My 6.4/8HP car with 3.09 gears, at about half the weight and twice as aerodynamic “can” get 22mpg + average if one were to clock it on some flat 55-60mph highway. It won’t get 22mpg avg even doing the speed limit on the freeway (70-80mph). Avg overall is around 19mpg. Zero chance any HD gasser pickup, new or old, gets 22 mpg or even anywhere near that regardless of speed or conditions unless the conditions are downhill with a tailwind. Lol
Yes gasser mpgs have increased a fair amount since 10-20 years ago. As has power and comfort. Whereas the mpg on light/med duty class 2-5 diesel trucks has stayed about the same since they got to be quite capable about 20 years ago. Except the early tier IV emissions models took a big hit in mpgs for a few years until the mfgs made the after treatment more efficient. Now they have way more power and gears than 20 years ago and still maintain similar mpg numbers.