Forum Discussion

DNJ's avatar
DNJ
Explorer
Oct 24, 2013

Class A to Hybrid: "Rightsizing" experiences?

Hi all,

Thanks in advance for any-and-all thoughts on this. Can't hurt my feelings, and interested in any perspective. Yes, I know I'm biasing my sample by asking the Hybrid forum, but figured the Class A forum would be biased in the opposite direction, and I *know* the benefits of the Class A...

Interested in hearing from anyone who has moved from a Class A, 5th Wheel or traditional travel trailer to a hybrid. In particular, were the trade-offs what you expected and are there any regrets and/or things to consider you'd like to share?

We currently own an entry level Class A that has been great to us (Four Winds Hurricane 33h). As our kids get older (15 and 12), their summer commitments have increased, and we expect to transition to more local camping (e.g., state campgrounds), three days to a week type of trips versus our 2-3 week ever-other-year cross-country romps we've taken with the Class A.

What we love about our Class A:

* She's taken us to so many great places, thus there are the memories;
* Built in levelers, 5+ KW generator, two ACs, decent room in the bathroom, tons of storage and CCC, etc.;
* Ability stop for lunch or potty breaks and not leave the vehicle;
* Easy, relatively safe, and efficient "quick" overnights (e.g., Love's Truck Stops) when "making time";
* Separate bedroom with room to change clothes, etc.

What we *think* we'd love regarding a hybrid (e.g., Roo 233 S):

* More of a "camping" experience regarding sights, sounds and open air;
* Separate "rooms" for son, daughter and parents (now we have to break down and set up a couch and dinette each and every night/morning);
* We now need a pick-up for other reasons (horse hauling and snowmobile hauling), needs we did not have before. Thus I'll be sinking cash into a tow vehicle (likely a F-150 with ecoboost) either way - Seems crazy to have the V-10 in the motor-home plus the towing capacity of my daily driver....

I realize we are giving some things up to gain others. We also know that we may be romanticizing the "outdoor" experience regarding the tent ends. However, we made the HUGE leap from tent camping to the Class A, and the tenter in me misses being outside at night. I will not, however, give up 2am bathroom access, nor an AC unit nor a fridge for beer (though the beer may be what makes the bathroom necessary...). Thus we are seriously considering the hybrid route.

Thank you for reading and, in advance, for any advice / experiences you are willing to share.

dnj
  • Another perspective .. went from pop up to hybrid and now to small5th wheel. Before making the leap, I'd suggest renting a hybrid. I really liked the feel of sleeping in a bunk which felt like a tent, but it required to be made and taken down each time. Also someone had to crawl over another. It was just annoying but doable. Stowage is also to be considered as the beds are not always up. The tents also needed to be dried after use. Setup and take down needs to be considered with weather too.

    I did enjoy the hybrid, but it followed a popup...many of your comments seem to me that the environment the class A provides is just right for your family... don't break something that is working well :-) we did our camping with 2 boys. You will need the room as the girls will want to bring friends.

    Try a unit before making the jump... email me if you have any questions
  • I'm not in exactly your situation but there are similarities. I do not have a hybrid....so I realize this doesn't address much of your questions, but to the extent it may be helpful to you here goes....

    I also have teens, and we also had a class A for several years. When my girls were a bit younger we traveled quite a bit, including some longer trips. They are now too busy for that amount of travel.

    3 years ago, we sold the Class A and ultimately purchased a Travel Trailer. Besides the scheduling issues, we were in the middle of adopting a 5th child. Finances were changing, and she has special needs so we are home a lot more now.

    What I have learned, which may help you:

    When you are too busy to use a motorhome often, there is a feeling of "guilt" or "wastefulness" for it to just be sitting there. Insurance costs, maintenance, perhaps monthly payments....all for nothing. That feeling is greatly diminished with a much less expensive asset.

    You also don't have as many maintenance concerns when the unit is sitting for extended periods.

    You are correct in that we tend to visit more state parks, COE campgrounds, etc than we did in the MH. It feels a bit more like camping.

    The downsides? Traveling in a motorhome is awesome. Bathroom breaks and lunch stops are easier....overnights are easy. You know all this, but you'll miss those things if you make the move.

    Also, selling a used motorhome can be tricky, especially if you have a loan on it. But it can be done. I sold mine through RVT.com. Took a couple months, but got more than if I'd wholesaled to one of the dealers that contacted me.

    Good luck!