I have bad luck with Goodyears; either they wear out really fast, have blowouts or separate. At any rate, they are debris magnets on any vehicle I've ever had them on. For the cash I would rather get a Toyo, Nitto or Firestone. The Dyna's seem to be well reviewed, also. Michelins are out due to size limits and cost. I can't get an AT2 in an "E" range over 265, at least in a 17.
The main issue I'm running into is the load range/availability of the sizes I want. I can get 315 "E" only in a Firestone/Bridgstone product, but are readily available and nationwide. Not knowing if I want something closer to a 285, which will open more options (285/75), but limit availability. I believe something close to a 34" would be ideal without much compromise.