+1 on any brand, but match size and the 4-way.
Keep in mind that if you or the previous owner upgraded tires to ones with max PSI >50 PSI, you likely need a different valve stem.
Of course, check for any leaks in the rim and tire.
I learned the valve stem issue first hand. When >50 PSI with old stems, they tend to leak down.
Your lug wrench/socket/etc should have VERY LITTLE wiggle when placed on a lugnut. Also make sure it is pushed on fully.
A tire that leaks down, even over a few days, is a recipe for disaster. Make sure it gets fixed and stays at MAX sidewall listed pressure.
Sorry you had troubles...