There were a number of factors that decided us on a large Teardrop trailer and a number of those addresses the concern I would have with a popup, wet canvas and sound.
I tented for 60 years and can remember a number of occasions packing up a wet tent and having to spread it on the solar cloths dryer when we got home, not a big deal with a three person tent. Camp grounds with folks that seem to think you share their taste in music, screaming kids, barking dog...
The tear enforces living out side our idea of camping.
The best thing 18 mpg on my Subaru Outback towing.
getting ready to camp hook up the TV load the food in the Waeco refrigerator and clothing and go.