Kayteg1 wrote:
CO is a product of incomplete combustion, common in neglected ovens and furnace, while high-efficiency engines don't produce much of it.
But they produce lot of other poisonous gases that you don't have sensors for, not to mention that even CO2 is not poisonous gas, but will kill you when you get too much of it replacing the oxygen.
Those who played Russian roulette with it can't post here anymore.
Sorry, but I have to hit the buzzer on this one. Not enough support this position.
1. CO is generally the product of combustion with less than optimum oxygen. All internal combustion engines produce CO-especially at less than ideal conditions such as idle. So do fuel powered space heaters. A catalyst heater will convert most of the CO to CO2. A charcoal BBQ is one of the worst appliances for producing CO and is probably responsible for most space heating CO deaths (more overseas than in US). All should have warnings about not using in enclosed and occupied spaces.
2. Please list the "lot of other poisonous gases" you are referring to. Parts per million (PPM) in generator exhaust would be helpful for this discussion. When we "smell" exhaust, we smell unburnt hydrocarbons, usually in very small concentrations. We are taught that CO and the other products of combustion are present when we smell exhaust.
3. Anytime we exchange air in our lungs at less than 21% oxygen (measured at sea level), we risk hypoxia. This could be from high altitude or entering a closed space where oxidation has taken place (sewer or grain silo). Hypoxia from too much CO2 would be extremely rare. Even pure engine exhaust is over 3/4 Nitrogen. Maybe possible if you were in a closed room where a CO2 fire suppression system was activated.
4. CO is poisonous at relatively low concentrations because it attaches preferentially to red blood cells, does not release readily, and blocks oxygen exchange in the lungs. It is not instantaneous but a cumulative effect. This is why it can be deadly over time.
I apologize in advance if this is TMI for this discussion.
FYI as a teenager, I almost succumbed to CO poisoning in a TC closed with a built in propane gas lantern. After a fellow worker was rescued from a hotel room with CO poisoning, I carry a portable CO detector whenever I am not sleeping at home (which, of course, has a CO detector) Two CO detectors in your TC is not redundant to me.