Drsolo writes
“There is a vin number on vehicles. The purpose of the vin number is that if the vehicle is stolen then the owner reports the vehicle stolen by its vin number. “
Vin number on a trailer and a VIN number on a vehicle with a motor are two different beasts.
As you SHOULD have noticed, trailers get treated DIFFERENTLY than automobiles.
“OTOH, when a person fills in the back side of the title it is a proof that the vehicle was sold. “Wrong.
Each state has it’s OWN SPECIFIC RULES that must be followed to the “T” if you want to successively be able to transfer “ownership” of a trailer (or even motor vehicle).
In PA you simply cannot “sign and fill out” the backside of a title yourself, PERIOD.
In PA you MUST sign the backside of the title only in the presence of a “Notary”, the Notary will fill in all the proper info and when you sign it they will apply their Notary seal.
In order to bring in a vehicle into PA from an individual the ORIGINAL title from the state the vehicle came from MUST have the back signed IN FRONT OF A NOTARY by the owner you purchased from and a Notary seal must be present.
For instance, I bought an antique auto from a gentleman in SC, SC however DOES NOT REQUIRE “notarization” off titles.. The owner simply signs the back and the new owner also signs the back..
I contacted my local Notary and specifically asked what I NEEDED TO DO in order to transfer an out of state title to PA..
In order for me to be able to transfer the title to my name in PA, the seller in SC HAD to locate a Notary and sign the title IN FRONT OF THE NOTARY and have the notary seal applied. The SELLER had to jump through some hoops to find a notary but they did.
Both the seller and myself FOLLOWED the rules that PA uses and I had NO TROUBLE in successfully transferring the title into my name.
“The title serves multiple purposes of being able to easily transport the information needed to a DMV window to change ownership, to get license plates and to pay taxes on the sales transaction. In Wisconsin there is no requirement for license plates on trailers under 3K lbs so many people dont bother to file for a title transfer and avoid paying for both title and sales tax. “Too “easy”, in fact anyone can simply forge a name and claim ownership.. That is why many states have specific rules on how to transfer ownership that must be followed. Imagine if someone grabbed YOUR title to YOUR RV and vehicles and forged YOUR name to the titles then they took possession of said vehicles and then proceeded to take them to another state.. If other states followed your logic the thief would have no problem getting a new title in a different state and you are left with nothing..
Not signing and properly transferring the title within your state to AVOID taxes is called tax evasion.. That is a whole ‘nuther discussion..
“Physical possession of the title, the vehicle and a sales receipt should be enough. But not in Florida. “Names on a title can be forged and a “sales receipt” both can be forged, two bogus forgings can equal a good title?
Anyone can scribble a name on a paper and say it is the owners signature and anyone can easily make a fake sales slip.. Without some PROOF or WITNESS that the signature is real you simply have a piece of paper and a big hulking doorstop.
You seem to think that Florida and all other states should have the same rules as your state of Wisconsin.. They DO NOT.. They have different rules for many reasons, most of the top reasons are for collecting taxes on the sale and for making sure it isn’t stolen.
“What I got is a clear title showing no liens, filled out and signed by a previous owner. All Florida has to do is check to see if the vin number shows up as stolen.”Wrong, what you have is an OPEN TITLE with no “liens”. You have no proof that the signature on the title is really the signature of the previous owner.. You NEED more proof that your friend NOW owns the trailer..
You should have found out up front what documentation FLORIDA REQUIRED before purchasing..Florida isn’t at “fault” for you and your friend not finding out and following ALL the rules BEFORE making the purchase..You would have been better off buying the trailer, having it put into your name, getting the new title then using that title (in your name) as the means of transferring to your friend in Florida..
Trailer VINs are treated differently from MOTOR VEHICLE VINs in most states.. Not to mention before 1980s many trailer VINs did not follow any common alpha/numeric sequence or even length making tracking stolen trailers pretty much a lost cause..
Trailers unlike motor vehicles also only have ONE location for the VIN which is typically stamped on the tongue, but not ALL trailers have the VIN stamped on, some used plates that were riveted on or even sticky labels.. This makes it far easier to wipe out (or “wash”) the OEM VIN..
Most modern day motor vehicles have at least TWO and in many cases THREE locations where the VIN can be found making it harder to wipe out the VIN..
Around my neck of the woods, folks junk water damaged trailers by tearing them down for scrap and sell the trailer frames with a title for $500 (folks buying the frame with title use this as a shortcut in order to build a new trailer)..