I need first hand experience from you all...please

I chose Carlisle Radial Trail RH in Load Range D. They are in-stock at most Discount Tire dealerships. Maxxis is typically a "special order" tire. That means, should you have a blowout on the road, you may have a wait if you wish to replace the bad tire immediately.

Carlisle sponsors the Bassmaster's tour and supplies tires for the boat trailers. If those guys can use them and make them last, it should be a good tire for the rest of us that don't put the hammer down.