Looking for real world feedback on these three TTs

If you can tow the additional weight, any kid of a slide out is great ! @ more to consider are the Jayco 184BS and the Coachman 193BHS.

If you are a first timer, I suggest you shop for a 2-4 year old unit. If you decide this is not for your family you won't loose as much money. Also, you will find out it the floor plan works for you and what features are really important. (How important is a sink in the bathroom ? I don't think you will know until you try not having one !)