Forum Discussion

tragusa3's avatar
tragusa3
Explorer
May 07, 2016

MPG improved with heavier tires???

Our F150 came with the stock P rated, SR-A Wranglers.

I didn't think they were as bad as most people claim, but if I needed new tires, why not try to eek out some improvement? So I debated going with another P tire or an LT. I ended up going with the Michelin Defender LTX M/S in an E load range.

From all of my research, I was expecting a bit stiffer ride, which I have now experienced and appreciate. I was also expecting to lose roughly 1 mpg due to the heavier tire. I stayed with the same size.

However, after 3-4 weeks, what I'm getting is about a 1-2 mpg increase on my work commute and a 4mpg increase on highway driving. A recent trip from Greenville to Gatlinburg (through the mountains on I40) I returned with a 23.5 mpg average on the truck computer (which is confirmed accurate).

What's going on? Could the quality of tire make that much difference? Less rolling resistance? Is the tire a different diameter and throwing off the computer? Whatever the case, I'll certainly be happy at around 23mpg on highway trips.

BTW, love the tire. Handling and noise are noticeably improved.
  • Actually the Michelin LTX series is known to gain a couple miles per gallon, not from being smaller in diameter, but better quality. As soon as the Good for a year SR-A's are worn on mine, I'll go directly back to Michelins.
  • However, after 3-4 weeks, what I'm getting is about a 1-2 mpg increase on my work commute and a 4mpg increase on highway driving. A recent trip from Greenville to Gatlinburg (through the mountains on I40) I returned with a 23.5 mpg average on the truck computer (which is confirmed accurate).


    There could be lots of things that account for the mileage increase. The bottom line is this. Those tires did not increase your mileage this much.

    If it were that easy to increase mileage on a truck by 4 MPG or even .5 MPG the manufactures would pay $1000 bucks a piece for those tires.

    My guess is your tire diameter messed up your mileage calculations.
  • Tread pattern, tread compound all play a role. Unless you know for certain the tire diameters are exactly the same you simply cannot compare.
  • It's possible that the tire diameter is a tad smaller and you're covering the same distance, but it's showing more miles on the odometer, hence it looks like you're getting better mileage. Not unusual for tires labeled the same size to actually measure a bit difference in diameter.
  • RoyB's avatar
    RoyB
    Explorer II
    I also get better gas mileage using the SHELL Gasoline for some reason...

    Roy Ken
  • I would imagine it's similar to pushing a loaded wheelbarrow with a soft tire compared to pushing one with a hard one.

    I put Defenders on our Rav4 (not LTX) and we really like them too.