btggraphix wrote:
Long Island has been doing it for a long time. Family members of mine lost their farmland in the late 40's that they had bought from the Matinicock Indians in the 1600's.....after they got surrounded by mansions (like JP Morgan's niece) and got taxed into oblivion. Can't have smelly cows next to those fine folks!
Good luck. That's pretty cra ppy.
What is the rest of the story? Did they actually "lose" the property, or did they sell it for a handsome profit? If it had been in the family since the 1600s, little chance they still owed a mortgage to the Indians. Doubt the land values fell below the 27 beads they gave the poor Indians in exchange for the property. If the land was surrounded by JP Morgan's relatives and the like, it probably had significant value. Were they so arrogant they just refused to pay the property taxes the rest of us have to pay? Did it come out that those long ago ancestors swindled the Indians and the government awarded it back to them?
As for the original post, unfortunately the interests of individuals often do not coincide. Usually the laws prohibiting commercial vehicles are passed due to some neighborhoods starting to look like giant billboards do to all the trucks with their signage. Most people don't want to look out their front windows and see the street lined with advertisements for killing bugs, delivering pizzas and handy numbers to reach a bail bondsman at a moment's notice. Some far sighted business people even have taken to parking their mobile billboards in strategic locations to gather the most eyeballs possible. A law such as the OP ran afoul of is the easiest way for a town to combat the issue. These laws are also almost exclusively enforced on a complaint basis. The odds are one of the OPs neighbors called and complained.
I think if the OP went to court with some photos and argued his case, he will probably win or at least be given a reprieve and told not to do it again. Then again, the judge may be the one who called the violation in, so like all court cases, nothing is black and white.