fj12ryder wrote:
ShinerBock wrote:
fj12ryder wrote:
Well, we can see how well prohibition worked when it came to controlling liquor. Just do some checking and read about the rise to power of organized crime, Al Capone and the like, on the sales/dealing of illegal alcohol. Making a product illegal doesn't really work, never has, never will.
The amount of alcohol related deaths is more than twice the amount of people killed by guns (including suicide, murder, and accidental) every year. Don't get me wrong I love my beer (as my name implies), but the fact is alcohol kills way more people per capita being legal than it did when it was illegal.
We're not discussing the legality/illegality question, but rather the groups that rise in power when something people want is made illegal, for whatever reason. The opium trade begat The Opium Wars, Prohibition brought forth Organized Crime and American gangsters, marijuana and modern drugs have delivered the Cartels and drug dealers from other countries. People will get what they crave, making it illegal simply means they will become criminals to do it.
I guess you missed my point. When comparing the implications of legalizing something versus not, you must take everything into account not just one side.
Yes, prohibition created more organized crime syndicates which created a lot of violence. However, most of this violence was toward the gangsters themselves. The flip side is that people dying from alcohol related accidents was likely way down.
With alcohol being legal it is the reverse. Deaths from organized crime is little to non existent while deaths and/or other injuries from other alcohol related accidents are way up. Alcohol being legal causes considerably more deaths and injuries than it did being illegal. And with prohibition, most of the people that died or injured were the gangsters themselves, not average citizens like it does with it being legal. Pick your poison as they say.
Again, I am an avid beer drinker and in no way trying to say we need prohibition again. I am just stating the facts.