So basically someone has literally had “bad luck” with the same tires that someone else thinks are “great”. This is inclusive of every tire and every internet story I’ve probably ever read.
Almost as fun as oil discussions except there largely isn’t a “bad” oil whereas poor quality or misapplication of tires is actually a real thing.
Tires just have so many other factors that those who don’t know Jack about vehicles fail to notice recognize or realize. And the tires are the visual outcome of other “issues.”