Forum Discussion

IDman's avatar
IDman
Explorer
Jan 01, 2015

Towing with Ram 2500, either 5.7 or 6.4 engine

We are going from diesel back to gasser and I will stick with a Ram 2500. We tow all over the West which, of course, means lots of mountains to climb so I would like the power and payload of the 6.4.

On the other hand, the truck will be my daily driver so I would lean toward the 5.7 for mpg. As I shop, research, and listen to others, I am realizing the best of each engine, BUT I am not hearing from others that tow in the mountains.

I would appreciate hearing from those who tow with either engine, in the 2500.

Please don't turn this into a brand war.

Thanks in advance and Happy New Year!

24 Replies

  • Why does RAM offer both 5.7 and 6.4 engines in their HD trucks? Must be a reason.
  • I have a 2014 1500 with the 5.7 which works well for my particular needs, but if I required a 2500 it would be powered by the 6.4 simply because of the RPM power range. You will read of the recommendation for 89 octane fuel for the 5.7 but in reality you will notice very little if any difference in actual driving. Towing, both engines will provide average mpg of around 8 to 10 depending on trailer size. Empty both will average 16 to 18. We drove our 5.7 1200 miles over Christmas,from south of Memphis to Charleston SC to Raleigh NC and back through the Smokies. No towing and mostly highway speeds in mid 70's. Average fuel burn was calculated at 19.8. With 87 fuel. If your towing requirements are within the range of the 5.7 specs, you will be very happy with it. If you need. A little more torque, get the 6.4. You will certainly be happy with either.
  • Let me know if you have any other questions.

    I forgot, I have a few other truck videos on YouTube I can link if you want.
  • I went from a history of two cummins diesels to the 6.4L Hemi.

    Mountain towing is not a problem with this engine. The rv I tow is a 37' 5th wheel that has 3 slides and weighs about 11000 to 11500#, depending on how much we pack. I live in the flat lands but always tow to the rockies. In the flats, we fight headwind. In the mountains we climb and descend grades.

    The 6.4L Hemi and previous 5.9L Cummins both climb the same grades at about the same speeds. The difference is that the Cummins did it in 3rd (4 speed auto) at about 2200 - 2400 RPM, and the 6.4L Hemi uses 2nd gear (6 speed auto) at ~5000 RPM.

    Towing mpg with the Cummins was 10-12, and the Hemi gets 7-9 mpg hauling the same RV over the same route. The diesel had 3.73 gears, the Hemi has 4.10s.

    On the mpg front, an important thing to note is that the 6.4L Hemi is able to switch into 4 cylinder mode when running empty, the 5.7L in the 2500 doesn't have that ability as it is not equipped with MDS. RAM engineers say the 6.4L Hemi will therefore get better mpg than the 5.7L (Video).

    Also, the 6.4L hemi has only slightly more power than the 5.7L, but it makes peak torque 800 - 1000 RPM lower than the 5.7L, GMs 6.0L Vortec, and the Ford 6.2L gas V8. That is what allows MDS to be used, and is great for towing. They accomplish this by using variable length intake runners. Good low end, then they change to add more top end power. If you listen carefully you can hear it happen when you floor it and the rpm climbs.

    Typically, my truck will haul my RV at 2200 RPM in 5th gear and hold there down the highway when in flat terrain.

    Here's a video of my truck towing my RV. Link