Insurance rates can vary wildly depending on where exactly you are in the country, the company, and your particular situation. In some places you can get full coverage for a little over $100 while in other parts of the country it will easily set you back $1000+ annually.
You aren't that far away from me and I would say that $736 is quite steep on a '14 Outback around these neck of the woods. When I looked, Progressive ended up being the cheapest for me so that's who I'm with. I would take the rate that Progressive is offering you as it looks like a good one. If you bundle then you can save even more.