Forum Discussion

OBX-GL's avatar
OBX-GL
Explorer
Aug 23, 2014

Who makes the best trailer ? - my answer

Nobody. What i have learned so far is - all trailers are junk, just of varying degrees.

One could easily assume from that comment i have a horror story to tell, i don’t, i love my trailer. I’m just realistic, time allowed my thinking to adjust from newbie delusions. Often asked here is "what is the best brand" as its a question i asked here myself back when i was first shopping around. I now tell my friends not to worry about brands and there reputation of quality, there is little differentiation. They all are capable of producing lemons from time to time. And, even if you avoid the lemon except that you will still have problems, even with a new trailer. My advice is to focus on the brands that have a rep for standing behind their warranty. Find a good dealer for service, acknowledge it may not be the one you purchase from. And. when something is loose,leaking,or crooked, don't make a mountain out of a mole hill, its camping after all. Most importantly, get handy.

I own a Heartland and will recommend them. They were great with the little warranty work needed, even went the extra distance addressing an issue well outside of warranty. I would buy another Heartland product.

Unfortunately there is very little differentiating Heartland or the many other brands available from one another. Methods of construction, materials used, and attention to quality differ little producing similar products. Its an odd industry. Duplication is everywhere, multiple brands within brands duplicating again. This achieving no real identity or advantage for manufacturer, no advantage for the consumer just more confusion. Also, this confusion is leading manufacturers to dilute brand equity that once saw a line or model thrive.

Having given my .02 i’m interested in others thoughts on why the industry is the way it is. Or, if you disagree with my ramblings. Has our RV culture settled for something less than we deserve ? Are we such a tight bunch because things are so . . .

59 Replies

  • I agree with you too. I would add that nobody even makes a super high quality (like a Mercede's of TT's) because they all use lousy materials and a complacent workforce.
  • I've had a Rockwood (Forest River) and a KZ Escape, each for 3 years. They did the job competently. But I am not sure I would have wanted to keep them for 10 or 20 years. Cabinets made of pressed board and stapled together do not impress me as high quality. The KZ's roof was the ugliest piece of work I've ever seen, but the TT was less than $10K new so I bought it anyway and it served its purpose, but at 3.5 years that roof started to leak.

    To you folks who think your trailer is/was of high quality, I haven't seen your brand so I can't comment on them. One brand that I do think is top notch quality (but they are rather small and quite pricey) is Oliver, built in TN.
  • I am glad to hear that you are somewhat satisfied with the Heartland products. I see the website and am excited to see a new Cyclone toyhauler, the new design with a side opening patio with TV set and refrigerator on the side.

    You can buy a higher quality fifth wheel or trailer from this company. http://www.horizonsrv.com/

    I probably would not buy a Horizons RV, but do know that they make great units, suitable for full time use. They are just to heavy and large for vacationing.

    Yes it is a balance between cost, weight, and durability. The more durable, the more expensive and heavy it will become! And you will be able to sell it for a lot more money when it is 10 years old.

    Happy camping!

    Fred.
  • We are almost ready for the next jump for the supposed last trailer for our retirememt. We like the TT idea and we have been for the last 10 years and wish to stay this way. Have looked at hundred to say the least. I must say most of what is mentioned is correct but there are differences if you look closer and read the fine print on spec sheets.

    A lot of things are the same as they all come from the same suppliers so it isn't going to make a lot of difference. Ever try to figure why one trailer ways a thousand more pounds than the other and has a thousand pounds more GVW than another comparable. Look at some of the frames. Compare a Fox or one of the Outdoors RV with the others. They make a much heavier fram and sides. My preference is these but saying that their QC on finishing isn't much better than these other we speak of all the time. I still see all kinds of things we shake our heads when we go through them.
    Now if you really want to do it up go look at and Excel Winslow. Weighs a ton more than the others, built like a tank, heavier walls etc etc. Just make sure you have a fat wallet and an mdt to pull it. Is it nicer, better quality etc? Absolutely but I still read of warranty issues of the QC dept origin.

    I think what we need to do as a consumer is demand better QC before coming out of the factories even if it results in a slightly higher cost. For those of us that are willing to pay more for better construction knock your socks off. Big thing is to at least make the unit so when it walks out of the showroom it is as good as it gets. For those that fall apart later then either warranty or look at the construction you bought and question yourself and the mfg.......
  • I definitely disagree with the OP on this statement: "What i have learned so far is - all trailers are junk, just of varying degrees."

    We have a Winnebago Minnie Winnie 2101DS which evolved from the Sunnybrook line that Winnebago bought. We looked at a lot of different trailers including going to 2 large RV shows before settling on the one we bought. We were looking at quality, design, and value. This trailer has lived up to all of those requirements. In no way can I consider this trailer to be junk to any degree.
  • its not who makes the best trailer , its who makes the best trailer for you at the price point you want to spend . I loved my $ 2500. mallard , It wasnt great , but it wasnt bad , but it was fun . I like my $ 7000 sunset creek , but I would like it a whole lot better if i got it for cheaper .
  • I also disagree with the OP.

    Northwoods Mfg and Lance both go the extra mile to make sure that things are done correctly. Lance uses some pretty high tech construction methods and also materials. Also OutdoorRV Mfg is doing something right too!
  • I disagree with the "nobody" comment. I have had two Sunnybrook trailers dating back to 1997. I still have the second one. Neither has ever had to go in for any kind of service. I have had to tighten, repair minor items myself but have never had to take it to the dealer for any kind of repairs.

    Had a set screw come loose on the slideout mechanism one time but a mobile repair man found it and fixed it in about 3 minutes. That is the only "major" problem that we have had.

    Sunnybrooks are now made by Winnabago so I cannot vouch for the quality of those rigs but our present rig has been faultless since the day we purchased it almost 10 years ago. I would say that is pretty darn good quality, and I certainly would not call it a "junk"! :)
    Barney
  • Agree with you.
    But I will say that it is amazing just how much our dollars will buy. Even though I wish that I could get some things upgraded from the factory. I realize that my priorities would not be the same as anyone else's. So to make everyones wishes come true... The manufacturers would have to upgrade many things, and the cost would go up a lot.
    Since I have advanced DIYer skills, I am pretty happy getting a good value and upgrading it to suit myself. I do look for certain features that will make my upgrades more feasible to do though.