Forum Discussion

DutchmenSport's avatar
Aug 24, 2016

Yup, another tire question? - same old... same old..

My Outback has the standard 15 inch tires that came from the factory. Trailer is 35 feet long and weight is suppose to be around 8000 pounds empty. We've had the trailer 3 years now and it's been towed a good 20 thousand (or more) miles. So I feel my tires served well.

Returned home last Monday from another mini-trip and when covering the tires (like I always do), I noticed one tire is balding some (really, a little beyond my comfort zone balding). I thought ... oh yuck! It's now MY turn. Talked to the wife and she didn't blink an eye... get new tires... the sooner, the better.

Last time I purchased TT tires was about 7 years ago. Got Carliles and they sold with the camper after being on the road 4 years. I never had problems with them. I've never had problems with any tire I've ever owned on 3 different TT,and all 3 TT's were factory installed tires. Normal wear and tear is expected. Reason I changed out those Duro's from my previous camper was because they started dry rotting (side walls cracking) after 5 years. So, I feeling I have good success with tires. But I know some have not.

I've kept up with the many threads and posts on RV.net, it seems the strongest contender is Maxxis tires.

So, I'm just going to toss it out there. Anyone who purchased TT or 5er tires in the last year or so, what did you get and why? No need to bash any brand, just ... what's good about the one you purchased and why?

I'm prone to go with Carliles again, because of price and they are easily obtained. Been reading on these forums that Carliles once had a bad reputation but that's changing. I never had problems with them. So, just wondering what's changed with them. But I don't mind going a little beyond for a better tire either if it can be proven there is such a thing as a "better" tire. So... what's your choice and logic for choosing it? Give me your BEST sales pitch!
  • If you have just one tire with excess wear, I would be looking at suspension parts and alignment.

    With all the noise about cheap imported tires, I just side-stepped all the nonsense and bought made in USA LT tires. Others can argue all they want, but you can drive on with peace of mind.

    My LT's look nearly new with more miles than you stated.
  • I bought Maxxis. Why? Because they had good reviews everywhere.

    Like you I have had very, very good luck with my trailer tires. Bias tires were getting really hard to find so I went with a Maxxis radial tire 2 years ago. They are black and round and seem to be just fine. But in all fairness, so were all my other cheap tires I had over 35 years.
  • I'm prone to go with Carliles again, because of price and they are easily obtained. So... what's your choice and logic for choosing it? Give me your BEST sales pitch!


    I would go with Carliles or Maxxis. However, I have had good luck with Tow Max tires. And not so good service out of Goodyear Marathons.
  • The new gen high speed rated ST tires like the Provider ST or Carlisle RH and especially the newest from Carlisle HD tires are the way to go if your going with a 15" tire for a 10k gvwr trailer.

    The best upgrade for trailers in the 10k -12k range/5.2k-6k axles would be 16" LT tires....if the trailer has 16" wheels.

    The Maxxis is a bit dated and we have had several members on this and other websites who had issues with them. Maxxis says not all their ST tire sizes has the nylon cap. I would check with them first to see if your size has the cap if you choose to go that way.
  • There is positive feedback from those who tow with the newer, redesigned Carlilse ST tires. As most of us know, Maxxis ST tires has been enjoying positive reviews for a number of years. Similarly, I have always got good service from our ST tires, even the cheap stock tires that came with our rig. I expect 4 years or 20K plus miles (whichever comes first) and we've been fortunate to get that and have never had any blowouts while towing.

    Contrary to what some perceive, any tire can be had and ordered by any reputable tire dealer. Heck, when Discount Tire tried to insinuate that Maxxis ST tires were scarce and difficult to get, I went home and ordered them online from DiscountTireDirect.com, had them on my doorstep 3 days later. He sure looked embarrassed when I brought them over to be mounted and balanced. There was no hard feelings, I realize it was his job to sell tires that provided the biggest profit margin.

    In the long run, LT tires are the best choice although available selection in a 15" tires is limited. For the most part, ST tires serve their purpose and are fine for rigs 10K# or less. I think either Maxxis or the redesigned Carlisle ST tire will be good choices, plus it's apparent you take good care of them which is paramount to the success of any brand ST tire. I did what others have done and went up a load rating for added safety margin.
  • The Carlisle RH tires I purchased have been great so far, although it's only been about 10 months.
  • We just put a set of Carlisle HD on my trailer in prep for a trip out west. I too have been reading all the commentary, and after talking with the guy at Discount Tire I decided that was a good option. I was told the tire was engineered from the ground up, and it was the best trailer tire he's seen in his sixteen years. I guess we'll see.

    I contacted the wheel mfgr. and was told the wheels are rated for 80psi. I bought 5 as I went up a size and load range so I'm sure I have plenty of tire.
  • fla-gypsy wrote:
    I bought Maxxis Load Range E to get some reserve capacity over the previous D rating. They have proven for me (I'm the only one I have to convince) to be about the best ST tire available.

    Exactly what I did...
  • What is the trailer GVWR?

    Currently running MAXXIS 205/75R15-D
    I would have gone 15" LT if they were not taller.
  • I bought Maxxis Load Range E to get some reserve capacity over the previous D rating. They have proven for me (I'm the only one I have to convince) to be about the best ST tire available.