Impulse24
Aug 06, 2017Explorer
Drag ?
I thought of putting this in the DIY section but thought it belonged here as it is a 5th wheel question. There has been many topics of does a wing benefit towing, and when everything is take into a...
Impulse24 wrote:I think you're confusing the wings you see on trucks pulling 5th wheels with the wings/streamliners seen on semis. The wings on pickup trucks are too far away from the front of the trailer to help much, if any, at all. The "wings" on semi trucks are almost touching the trailer and are of the same height. They will work, wings on pickups not so much.
I appreciate the reply, and fully understand your point, however a study at Institute of Fluid Science Tohoku University 2-1-1, Katahira, Aoba-Ku, Sendai JAPAN, Using a wind tunnel showed that a short bed truck had little effect on drag and a large bed truck created a lot of drag while and driving with the tailgate down was even worse for both vehicles. The Geometry of the Truck Bed also made a difference, but as most truck beds in the USA are within the same geometry field I don't see a big comparative difference.
I'm my scenario, I am in essence reducing a long bed to a short bed, but the area behind the cab to where it becomes a short bed is a question I don't have an answer for, nor does this study give any idea of how the drag is increased or decreased when a trailer is attached.
The wing, as has been stated many times does work, If it didn't the Commercial Industry would not be using it, Plus assuming all other aspects are in tune and maintained the distance between the wing and the trailer is the biggest determining factor of efficiency. I agree that a cap with a curve is more stream lined than a brick wall cap, and there are caps with contorted shapes creating a stream line effect. But again the distance between the back of the truck and the cap on the trailer is an unknown..
In theory it should reduce drag I guess trial and error will provide the answer...
Thanks