cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Best Manufacturer And How Long Do We Go

FULLTIMEWANABE
Explorer
Explorer
Well the time seems to have finally come, hubby is winning out on his desire for a DP. Seriously thinking now of upgrading our 2003 37ft Gas Southwind RV to one of the following:

Manufacturer we are totally torn about as changes have occurred over the years and we've monitored those that have had issues upon new deliveries. Don't get me wrong I understand that there'll be a few teething problems, but we have a huge problem with spending hundreds of thousands on a rig for it not to have gone through the utmost Quality control to avoid a lot of this. Dealerships in our early years were a nightmare for us, just commission focused and would tell you anything it felt like, albeit the one we purchased our 5er off initially and then our Gas A was awesome, but we went through a lot of questionable sales people till we found them.

Newmar (now taken over by Winnibago so what's going to change on reliability/quality?)
Entegra (now part of the big Thor conglomerate, so how reliable/quality now?)
Tiffin - (quality/responsiveness to issues going forwards as Bob's son's taking over?)

So about 4 years ago, I stumbled upon a lovely Tiffin 37ft floorpan with a two access doored roomy bathroom. (biggest bone of contention is our small bathroom past 17 years). Loved the overall floor plan but not sure about the quality of doors hanging off hinges and some other things.

Newmar's reputation for years has been out there, but we were put off by over elaborate ceilings
and too many mirrors and bevelled edged ones sparkling at us (think Joan Collins in Dynasty = NAH). I believe they used to have a 3 year warranty that reduced and talking to those in service bays they told us fantastic stories on the service/warranty they received from Newmar on even little things in Year 3 being replaced.

Entegra - the reputation a few years back with Joyce resolving and handling many issues was huge on the forums, and we liked a lot. However, we wonder how that might have changed with the sell out and take over of a very large volume company today? Followed a few that had a couple of "rogue" rigs for want of a better description ?2014 timeframe.

Tiffin - over the years it seems there's been almost a close to "cult" following of Bob Tiffin, and for sure we've heard of some unsavoury experiences on new build deliveries a few years ago through Lazy Daze. What one person went through for 5 months on their lot was atrocious and should have been a second new build from scratch again rig instead of a constant battle for months before delivery of the second rig. One guy who's doors were falling off his cabinetry and he had a 69 point list of defunct items (that's way too many if it'd undergone a good quality control check prior). Bob does seem to be customer satisfaction focused for reputation, however, he is stepping down more and more and the younger more, more profit focused generation is stepping into play. Our concerns here are is this going to be at the expense of bad quality or service going forwards.

I absolutely would consider a second hand rig, hubby not so inclined (shiny new syndrome). I know for the sure the toilets would be the first thing pulled out and changed by him, and anything connected to that likely!

So besides our dilemma of which manufacturer, we love several floorpans of the above, ranging from 37ft to the 45ft Cornerstone, so therein lies the second issue. How much would it affect us going to 40ft, 42ft, 45ft. We typically hate campgrounds so boondock by lakes, rivers, streams, mountains etc where we can fish, so that has to be forefront of our considerations for accessing being right besides these type of locations.

Thirdly, I said to him, what about the Tailswing at traffic lights and junctions when turning in higher populated areas we sometimes go through with a big 45ft???

Fourthly - How hard are all these new coach systems to get to grip with? DEF, VEGA TOUCH, AQUAHOT, SOLAR Arrays, Automatic this that and the other. How much goes wrong with them? How much extra maintenance? Must admit after watching many of Angie NIRVC videos I do like how much tidier and easier access today the coaches seem to filters, batteries etc.

Right now, thanks to awesome folks like you over the years on these forums, we've learnt to be able to do soooooo much on our current rig - from winterising, oil, filter changes engine & generator, monthly maintenance, hub oils, greasing and U bolts, replacing Norcold with residential as well Tube TV's with flat. Designing a 1000w 800a solar system and so much more. We'd like a coach that we can easily maintain as much as we can ourselves. Knowing it's generally done right and in our time frame not months in a facility or otherwise.

I'm a great believer that it's all fine and dandy paying a hefty price up front for a house whether static or on wheels but it's the ongoing running costs one needs to be cognisant of in the big scheme of things so .........

Really looking forward to your constructive feedbacks on what you'd be seriously thinking and why if you rolled like we do = travelling not sitting for months at a time! Boondocking not campgrounds ideally maintaining ourselves more than using third parties.

As always thanks in advance to all that share so much here.
It Takes No More Effort To Aim High Than To Aim Low - Reach For The Stars
11 REPLIES 11

Ivylog
Explorer III
Explorer III
This is the floor plan of our 45’ 08 Navigator except it has a computer desk behind the driver’s seat. A couple key features: with a second sink and wardrobe in the BR, it’s more open than most. Both the shower and bathroom are larger than normal. There is not a window over the head of the bed...warmer in winter and less noise. The ceiling fan makes up for no window. The kitchen has the most counter space of any RV I’ve ever owned.



Take a look at this 09 Monaco Executive...price is right.
This post is my opinion (free advice). It is not intended to influence anyone's judgment nor do I advocate anyone do what I propose.
Sold 04 Dynasty to our son after 14 great years.
Upgraded with a 08 HR Navigator 45’...

Ivylog
Explorer III
Explorer III
PM sent...42’ as you can srink it to 40’ for Rec.gov search.
This post is my opinion (free advice). It is not intended to influence anyone's judgment nor do I advocate anyone do what I propose.
Sold 04 Dynasty to our son after 14 great years.
Upgraded with a 08 HR Navigator 45’...

CA_Traveler
Explorer III
Explorer III
When/if I consider a 5er it would definitely be New Horizons.

Recently I saw a video of their 2021 5er frame only with no internal steps. I can't find that link - does anyone have it? Thanks
2009 Holiday Rambler 42' Scepter with ISL 400 Cummins
750 Watts Solar Morningstar MPPT 60 Controller
2014 Grand Cherokee Overland

Bob

Dick_B
Explorer
Explorer
Check out these folks: https://horizonsrv.com/
Dick_B
2003 SunnyBrook 27FKS
2011 3/4 T Chevrolet Suburban
Equal-i-zer Hitch
One wife, two electric bikes (both Currie Tech Path+ models)

Thermoguy
Explorer II
Explorer II
I don't have the pocket book to look at coaches of this caliber, but whenever I look at what I would buy if I did, I often look at the Renegade. With the Freightliner chassis and high quality interiors, it seems like one of the better rigs on the market. Not sure if these are in the same category and understand the Renegade is a Super-C, but in my opinion very nice and not owned by Winnibago or one of the average quality manufacturers...

Good Luck on your search - wish I was in your position.

wanderingaimles
Explorer
Explorer
I'm curious, with the lines your mentioning, why wasn't Nexus part of the possible choices? These are all outside my purse but I had thought Nexus was in the same category so just curious why it's not part of the question?

FULLTIMEWANABE
Explorer
Explorer
Thank you ED for that useful information. Looks like we are down to two potential manufacturers now! Yes the dealer is the key I guess or annual trips to the mothership! Thanks for highlighting the weight consideration.

CATraveler - thanks for the kind initial comment. I'm a bit like a sponge, have been trawling forums for 20+ years gathering and adding so much info to many spreadsheets. I"m also a speed typist so that helps hugely LOL. So length isn't the issue I thought it might be then? I'm conscious of our current 37ft but was concerned how much increased tail swing going longer? For sure I've almost been wiped out many a time by a trucker turning outside his lane and not paying attention! Another one that's had a less than stellar time with their rigs - life shouldn't have to be such a battle to get what you paid for! Alas it's the nature of the industry and with consumer demands right now they'll keep getting away with it, and worse sadly.

I've heard a lot of good on used Foretravels, but they've never really appealed to us of what we've seen.

Thanks again folks, looking forward to more feedbacks and thoughts from ya'll.
It Takes No More Effort To Aim High Than To Aim Low - Reach For The Stars

CA_Traveler
Explorer III
Explorer III
Sure know what you mean by quality. In 2004 or HR DP had 73 warranty items. We spent 3 weeks in 2011 while the current 2009 rig underwent the repairs as a condition of purchase. Yes only 2 years old.

Two repairs I'll never forget. Pugged in the household test to check the plugs. All good until I got to the 3 kitchen plugs with a open ground. They found a junction box where the ground wire was not connected by Monaco - yup It didn't just come loose, never connected. The front A/C didn't work. Dometic waffled for 2.5 weeks until I said enough. They finally fessed up to a recall and promised a new A/C which we got 4 months later. They had insisited a replacement was shipped and was at the Portland distributor and blamed them. If we had driven off the lot first it would have been our dime.
2009 Holiday Rambler 42' Scepter with ISL 400 Cummins
750 Watts Solar Morningstar MPPT 60 Controller
2014 Grand Cherokee Overland

Bob

CA_Traveler
Explorer III
Explorer III
Wow! This is hands down the BEST and well thought out post of someone considering a new RV in the 16 years I've been on this board!

Tailswing is not a issue. Turning a long rig needs planning. Have you ever watched a trucker turn to the right? They turn left first to get needed clearance and then right. Sure if you park close to a pole and pull out with a sharp right, hello insurance...

Big MHs are expensive as is maintenance. I'll get tires next summer and this is a case where I just hold up the CC - 8x$600 = $5k won't surprise me. Not saying I like it...

If I wasn't concerned about some bucks to help GCs and DW would let me I would.
1. Be concerned about Winnie owning Newmar - A downward trend won't be a shock.
2. Would consider Foretravel. For new ones I'd have a significant discussion about the Newmar chassis with Winnie in that pilot seat...

Keep us informed.
2009 Holiday Rambler 42' Scepter with ISL 400 Cummins
750 Watts Solar Morningstar MPPT 60 Controller
2014 Grand Cherokee Overland

Bob

azdryheat
Explorer
Explorer
Find the floor plan you like and go with it.
2013 Chevy 3500HD CC dually
2014 Voltage 3600 toy hauler
2019 RZR 1000XP TRE

Ed_C
Explorer
Explorer
Newmar and Entegra are in the same league. They have "hung wall" construction, as their main quality.
Either is very capable of boondocking especially if you do your "solar thing" however all though they are very maneuverable they are very heavy ,43,000 lb for the smallest and they need a secure footing.
One of us likes the Entegra interiors better, otherwise it's a toss up.
Find the right dealer!
Ed/Jeanie & Slade the GSD
2017 Entegra Aspire 42 RBQ/ Sierra Crew