Forum Discussion

scdiver's avatar
scdiver
Explorer II
Dec 07, 2014

Could use some generator help

My son has a Onan 4.0 model bge-1r on his 1985 class c that is not working correctly. New carb, points, coil and main bd. Engine runs strong and steady. Power at start up is about 90 volts 6 hertz. As it warms up the volt picks up to 118 volts. When a load is added the voltage drops but the engine does not speed up to cover the load. I'm thinking that the governor is not working.

I know nothing about generators so I'm wondering if any one can give me some pointers or some thing to look at first? Or maybe a link to a repair manual.

Thanks
Steven
  • On my 1995 Generac when I turn on an air conditioner the generator has to dig in to stay running. There is definitely a throttle increase. On my son's Onan when the air conditioner is turned on the generator stops. This has led me to think it's the governor.
  • The engine is not operating at the correct speed to maintain voltage and frequency.
    That is if the OP's frequency is a typo. If it is not a typo then the voltage regulator is suspect.
    I replaced mine with one from Flight systems
  • wa8yxm's avatar
    wa8yxm
    Explorer III
    An ideal generator of the common generator type the motor will run at a constant speed, 3600 RPM, 2400 RPM and 1200 RPM are common engine speeds, (others are possible) but it should be locked on that speed and never change Oh they do, but they should not.

    Sound will change, becoming deeper and throater as load increases, but speed should NEVER change on a traditional generator.

    (A sudden change in load may make it surge or dip but it should quickly return to 3600 or something that relates to it (2400, 1200 and such)

    INVERTER generators like the famous Honda EU-#000i series, those the engine changes speed with load, But not the traditional generator.

    As others have said, though... you do have a problem, i am guessing the voltage regulator BUT I STRESS THE WORD GUESSING!!!
  • does the engine slow down a little
    or Hold steady
    if the engine slows down, then it could be a Governor issue
    IF the speed holds even .while the voltage drops, then it is in the voltage regulator section of the control board
    and it likely needs a new control board

    the governor is mechanical and unless the linkage is sticky, very little goes wrong, unless a spring breaks in the linkage.. which often results in Hunting aka speed variation

    control board failure happens more than governor failure
  • you will find some troubleshooting guides at
    http://www.flightsystems.com/troubleshooting/
  • I assume that's a typo for 60 Hz (rather than 6 Hz) at startup.

    The governor should keep the engine speed pretty much steady, not varying greatly with load. Generator frequency, assuming it's not an inverter generator (which most or all RV generators are not), is directly tied to the engine speed; if it's 60 Hz ± a bit, the governor is operating properly.

    This sounds to me more like a failure in the voltage regulation system. The "Tech Issues" forum is where you'll most likely find generator experts here; maybe some kind moderator can move this thread over there.
  • Voltage and frequency is adjusted by engine speed in some older units. Should be near 130 volts and 60-62 on frequency.

About RV Tips & Tricks

Looking for advice before your next adventure? Look no further.25,106 PostsLatest Activity: Jan 26, 2025