Go with the GY ENDURANCE as they have been on the market for over 5 years with ZERO reported non road hazard claims.
First thing the naysayers said "they have not been on the market long enough". Then with years racking up they gave up on that claim and the only thing they can say now is "the tread is too thin". Well I am here to tell you I have plenty of tread left at 20k on mine that are dated 2517. They get driven nearly every day on my heavy Boat trailer at 70mph during the 6 Summer months. They are dropped into Salt water twice each trip. They get the heck "scrubbed out of them at the rough gravel parking lot/ and launch.
OH they also set on a concrete floor for 6 month at a time every winter.