tmas wrote:
Thanks. I have a 2009 Silverado. Looking at a 28 foot Salem, ~6000#. I think I'll go with the dealer hitch and trade up later if I want to.
One more question. What's the difference between a cheap brake controller and the top of the line?
Between the two hitches go with the Blue Ox sway pro.
"cheap" brake controllers may not be "cheap" on price so let's throw that vernacular out the window (common mistake on these forums).. No brake controller you will look at will be labeled "junk" or "cheaply made".
There are two primary brake controller designs. And the packaging will indicate either Time Based or Proportional.
1) Time Based (often referred to as Junk or Cheap on here). What a time bead brake controller does is ramp up the amount of trailer braking power from zero to a full power setting. The "more expensive" time based controllers allow you to set not only the power on the brake controller but the amount of time it takes from the moment you touch the brake pedal to the time that the trailer brakes are full power. Typically you can set the "ramp up time" from 0-5 seconds.
There are cheaper Time Based brake controllers who only let you set the power. The ramp up time is preset around 3 seconds. However the power to the trailer brakes is fully adjustable, typically by a big easy to access power adjustment wheel.
The best time based controllers IMHO from the expensive category are the Draw-Tite Activator II and the Activator III. The Cheaper time based controllers that perform well is the Hayes Sycronizer (my personal favorite time based controller) and the Reese POD
Time based controllers are more jerky in some cases because if you set it perfect for slow conditions around town you may not have enough power on the highway. What a lot of people will do is reduce power to the trailer brakes for stop and go, or in town Traffic and then increase the power to the trailer brakes on the highway.
A few of the advantages to a time based brake controller is that the control is solid state and requires no leveling. Just mount it, wire it, and it will work. If the tv skids while applying brakes the trailer will still get a brake signal.
2) Proportional brake controllers send the brake power to the trailer in proportion to how fast the tow vehicle is stopping. There are a lot of different kinds of proportional controllers out there. But the two best are the Prodigy P2 or P3 controller (at least that's the seeming consensus on here). The prodigy's "self levels itself" so it's a little easier to mount. There is also another type of proportional controller that requires you to set the level. Set either proportional controller up per the instructions and they will serve you well with much less jerking. When properly set a proportional brake controller is nearly set it and forget it.
Generally the overwhelming recommendation is to get the proportional controller. Either the time based or the proportional will stop the trailer and both have a manual override so you can manually activate the trailer brakes apart demo the tow vehicle.
I have used both types of brake control and both were capable is safely stopping the trailer. After I got use to the power adjustment for conditions my time based experience became better. Proportional was very very nice after it was set correctly.
Sorry for the book!
Jeremiah