dturm wrote:
352 wrote:
You are aware that what kills the fleas kills the dog? Bluntly put. Research it!!!!!!!
I was going to let this go, but I just have to respond :)
This is a very sensational statement long on drama and short on facts. If you have research supporting your assertion, show it.
Have there been deaths reportedly associated with flea products? YES.
These terrible situations have been thoroughly investigated and fit into categories of:
1. owner error (using dog product on cats), improper dosing (using large dog dose on small dog)
2. specific product related problem (a specific Hartz product was implicated a few years ago)
3. use on a sick/debilitated animal
4. use of a product that was tampered with - specifically counterfeit product usually purchases cheaply on the internet from unknown sources.
What these sensational stories/statements fail to mention is that serious diseases ARE transmitted or spread by fleas and ticks and are a threat to people as well as your pets. Fleas and ticks are not just a nuisance.
Responses have mentioned Lyme disease, but other diseases happen as well: Bartonellosis, Erlichiosis, Rickettsial diseases (several including Rocky Mtn Spotted Fever), Meningoencephalitis, tapeworms, and most frightening to me is that there are new ones showing up that we don't know about.
One other note, in 37 years of practice I have not seen a single death from a flea/tick product; and that includes many years when the products used were not as safe as the spot ons we now have.
Reactions were not usual, but not uncommon - those being topical irritation where the spot on was applied.
BTW, advantix is labeled for use in puppies as young as 7 wks of age. Just make sure you use the appropriate size for the weight of the puppy.
Doug, DVM
I agree with you, to a point. What you do not mention is the use on an older dog(what is the definition of an older dog, who knows that answer?) The companies that sell these products, readily agree, they could cause damage to an older dog... Not just the sickly dogs as is commonly believed. The drugs filter through the liver and kidneys. As you well know, the older we get, the older the organs. As an example, children have better longevity after chemo because their organs are younger. Whether it be chemo or flea medicine, what you put into the body to kill the causative organisms can kill the user. After we lost two of our healthy older best friends from kidney failure, who were treated with top of the line flea products, advised and monitored by our DVM, we started our search. Like you, our DVM was not sold that it was the flea products, until he himself started to see his older clients passing away from one particular top of line product, usually from kidney failure. He no longer refers his clients to flea products after the age of seven years.