I did a bit of searching on the net and from what I found I would use them. They have the same basic ID and OD and I think the double lip seal would seal a bit better than the single lip seal anyway. I couldn't find a single webpage to compare on so here are two pages with the measurements.
I had a good link to RocketSeals.com but I think their website is having problems. Here's the link anyway.
RocketSealsAnd here's an ebay link that has the size if you scroll down.
17146
And the link for 58846
58846