cancel
Showing results forย 
Search instead forย 
Did you mean:ย 

DISASTER - Nightmare Trip Report

BMW442
Explorer
Explorer
Ohhhhhhh man

So, my wife & I have been planning this trip for months. 12 days, Massachusetts to Amish Country, then Virginia, then North Carolina, then the beaches of SC. We were able to score reservations for 3 beachfront state parks, and were also gonna do 2 nights at a hotel in Charleston. Heading out in our 1985 Palomino Mini L pop-up that we got for free last summer. It's a little rough around the edges for sure, but we fixed it up a bunch and took it on the maiden voyage last November. It was great, but because of the polar vortex and early snow we only spent 4 nights in it. This was gonna be out big trip and last hurrah of the offseason (we run our own business May - Nov).

We hit the road last thursday, after doing some last minute touch-up work, fresh coat of paint, etc. Fully loaded & good to go. So psyched to get out of the perms-winter we've been having (it snowed here again last night) and relax down south.

Three hours into the trip, we're driving on the New York Thruway en route to Roadside America in PA. I see something kind funny in the rear view mirror, then see the TC door bust open, and the ENTIRE ROOF flys off the top of the camper! The truck behind us skids out to avoid it, hits the guardrail, and goes into the median. We pull over to the other side, totally freaking out, while the rest of the roofless TC is basically shredded to pieces in the back of our truck.

THANK GOD nobody was hurt. Nobody hit the roof (now laying in the road) and the people behind us were fine, they drove up and talked to us for a while afterwards. The state trooper was surprisingly low-key, and told us he wasn't even sure if it would be classified an accident because nobody hit anybody else. We didn't get a ticket for anything, but spent the next few hours dealing with the tow guys. We had to get the roof towed on a flatbed, then get our truck towed, then get the wrecked TC taken off and towed to a junkyard. All told it was over $500, plus now we've got no camper and all of our stuff jammed into the truck & bed, and we haven't even made it 200 miles from home yet.

We're both pretty much still in shock at this point, trying to figure out what to do next. So we end up at this random old school "couples retreat" resort in the Poconos, basically just pounding drinks & trying to calm down, chilling out in a crazy room with a heart-shaped jacuzzi and twinkling star lights above the round bed. It was actually a really cool (if kinda corny) spot called Cove Haven. Aside from the really bad food it's worth a visit. They had a weird sports bar game room where we played pool, mini golf, indoor archery, shuffleboard, and basketball. Plus a lake, horses, etc. We saw about a dozen deer and fed them out of our hands.

Ok, so next day, we figure hey, the worst is over, atleast we got that out of the way on day one, nobody was hurt, it could've been WAY worse. We've still got our tent and all of the bedding and food and gear from the camper, we're not gonna let this wreck our vacation. We're only 2 hours from Roadside America, we'll hit that up, have lunch, and make out way down towards Shenandoah.

Looking at the weather, we see it's pouring rain there, so we decide to get some big plastic bins and tarps so we can get everything organized & packed away in the truck bed. We pull up at a Dollar General in Hamburg PA and get all our stuff together in the back. Of course now we're super paranoid about things flying out, so we've got a million tie-downs & bungee cords holding everything down. Then as we are putting on the last one, it slips out of the hook, shoots back, and hits my wife in the eye.

Luckily it missed her eye ball by about 1 centimeter, hitting her on the bone right above it. We're still completely freaking out, it blows up to the size of a golf ball, and is dark dark purple. I find an urgent care center 2 towns away and we spend the next couple hours there getting 8 x-rays and doing tests to make sure she doesn't have a concussion. At this point, we're like, this whole trip is cursed. We'll be lucky to make it home alive.

So we spend the night in Reading at some dumpy hotel downtown, then the next day we go to Kuttzville to the big flea market/farmer's market, which was pretty cool, had some great food & scored an old Woolrich hunting coat for $25. Then we saw some hex signs on barns and did a tour at Crystal Caves which was also neat, but everywhere we go EVERYbody is staring at us. Her because of her eye (now a gigantic shiner) and me because they think I'm beating her relentlessly.

So then we start heading home and end up about halfway there, in Cooperstown NY, where we stayed at a really nice place (The Cooper Inn), had some great grilled chicken at this old school place called Brooks BBQ in Oneonta, and went to the Baseball Hall of Fame (which is awesome) on Easter. Ended up spending another night there just for the heck of it, then made it home without incident on monday.

Like I said, things could have been much much worse all around. The roof could've gone right through somebody's windshield and/or caused a huge pile up. The bungee cord could've gone a little lower, and my wife definitely would have lost the eye. In the end, the "free" camper ended up costing $2000 ($1500 worth of work we did, and $500 to scrap it) which adds up to $500 per night we actually spent in it.

We still want to get another (substantially newer & in better shape) TC, but realistically after this fiasco that's probably several years off. We both still like tent camping, so we will go back to that for this summer atleast. I probably won't be on this site much for a while, but want to say thank you to everybody on here, you guys are great with the advice & suggestions for newbies like myself.

I'll be back when & if we get a new set up, but until then take care, happy travels, and be safe!
39 REPLIES 39

billtex
Explorer II
Explorer II
whizbang wrote:
It was a miracle nobody got hurt by the roof.

Any ideas on why it flew off?

Sounds like an ID Ten T error...
2020 F350 CC LB
Eagle Cap 850
25'Airstream Excella
"Good People Drink Good Beer"-Hunter S Thompson

whizbang
Explorer II
Explorer II
It was a miracle nobody got hurt by the roof.

Any ideas on why it flew off?
Whizbang
2002 Winnebago Minnie
http://www.raincityhome.com/RAWH/index.htm

Bonesquatch
Explorer
Explorer
Damn.
And here I was feeling put out because I fried my phone in the mangroves last week while kayaking. Glad you guys are ok and nobody got hurt or worse.
Good luck on your next trip!
"That's just...like...your opinion...man..."--The Dude
2012 Chevy 2500 HD
2012 Lance 850

sabconsulting
Explorer
Explorer
Sorry to hear of your accident.

I forgot to latch the pop-up roof down once on a 4x4 camper in Namibia. Driving along the road at 60 there suddenly seemed one heck of a head-wind and the truck was really struggling, then I noticed people were flashing their lights at me. Luckily the only damage done was some lightweight vent material ripped, which I was able to repair with a cheap sewing kit at the next town. But it did make me think that I was really lucky.

Steve.
'07 Ford Ranger XLT Supercab diesel + '91 Shadow Cruiser - Sky Cruiser 1
'98 Jeep TJ 4.0
'15 Ford Fiesta ST
'09 Fiat Panda 1.2

RickW
Explorer III
Explorer III
silversand wrote:
...the last time we saw a pop-up driving down an Interstate with the roof up, it was I25 north of Denver. Incredibly, an Outfitter camper, blasting along the interstate WITH ROOF FULLY DEPLOYED traveling in the opposite direction. We can only assume that the rig was traveling at 65 to 75 MPH. Everything looked none the worse for wear (ie. perfectly stable).

Glad no one was hurt. Thinking about the myriad possible disastrous outcomes makes me think twice to ever want to venture out onto the Intertate highways following cargo-laden vehicles.

It also makes you wonder and consider how secure the roof clamp-downs are. I check ours before every outing, and replace the stainless screws into the camper sidewall aluminum framing with marine adhesive at ~4 year intervals. And check the roof-fascia integrity constantly.


On one of my first outings, I forgot to latch the roof. I was driving normally but could not get over 45 mph. Pulled over and, sure enough, the roof raised itself (Bernoulli effect). Nothing broke. I put red reflective tape on the inside of the latches and always use the checklist before putting the truck in drive.
Rick
04 GMC 1500 4X4X4, 04 Sunlite SB

ckwjl
Explorer
Explorer
BMW442 wrote:
The truck behind us skids out to avoid it, hits the guardrail, and goes into the median.


Sounds like the people behind you encountered their own nightmare as well. Iโ€™ll bet you did thank God they were not hurt! What is the extent of the damage to their truck?

kennyzzz
Explorer
Explorer
In the end, the "free" camper ended up costing $2000 ($1500 worth of work we did, and $500 to scrap it) which adds up to $500 per night we actually spent in it.

well I've got 12500 into mine and used it 45 nights in 5 years.. was not the best decision i made buying it.
Chevy 2008 1500 X-cab 5.3 373 posi 4x4 z-71
2003 jayco quest 190 4059 lbs.
2004 Northern light 8.5

silversand
Explorer
Explorer
...the last time we saw a pop-up driving down an Interstate with the roof up, it was I25 north of Denver. Incredibly, an Outfitter camper, blasting along the interstate WITH ROOF FULLY DEPLOYED traveling in the opposite direction. We can only assume that the rig was traveling at 65 to 75 MPH. Everything looked none the worse for wear (ie. perfectly stable).

Glad no one was hurt. Thinking about the myriad possible disastrous outcomes makes me think twice to ever want to venture out onto the Intertate highways following cargo-laden vehicles.

It also makes you wonder and consider how secure the roof clamp-downs are. I check ours before every outing, and replace the stainless screws into the camper sidewall aluminum framing with marine adhesive at ~4 year intervals. And check the roof-fascia integrity constantly.
Silver
2004 Chevy Silverado 2500HD 4x4 6.0L Ext/LB Tow Package 4L80E Michelin AT2s| Outfitter Caribou

AISURFFISH
Explorer
Explorer
Travelon wrote:
A Trip Report without pictures is like it never happened. :B

Travelon



x2
2017 F350 6.2L Crew Cab

Arctic Fox 990 2021 TORK-LIFT FAST GUNS AND SUPER HITCH
COOLER RACK OFF THE FRONT ALWAYS FULL OF FISHING RODS TICA TO BE EXACT

markandkim
Explorer II
Explorer II
Thank God no one was hurt.

I will never follow junk down the road.

Sounds like it wasn't anywhere near road worthy to start with.

Hope your wife recovers fast.
Retired Navy

2020 Ram 2500 Bighorn 6.7L
2014 Crossroads Zinger 27RL
2022 Grand Design Reflection 315RLTS

rockhillmanor
Explorer
Explorer
Well look at it this way. You had so much happen on one trip that from here on in nothing that will happen to you RV'ing will ever seem so bad.:W

so we've got a million tie-downs & bungee cords holding everything down. Then as we are putting on the last one, it slips out of the hook, shoots back, and hits my wife in the eye.

Luckily it missed her eye ball by about 1 centimeter, hitting her on the bone right above it. We're still completely freaking out, it blows up to the size of a golf ball, and is dark dark purple. I find an urgent care center 2 towns away and we spend the next couple hours there getting 8 x-rays and doing tests to make sure she doesn't have a concussion...


I got hit 'once' with a bungee cord. Just missing my eye also. This was a big big wake up call for me regarding bungee cords.

Bungees are now BANNED from use anywhere in my RV or in fact anywhere near me. I use ratchet straps or those new long rubber coated big wire tires.

We must be willing to get rid of the life we've planned,
so as to have the life that is waiting for us.

Travelon
Explorer
Explorer
A Trip Report without pictures is like it never happened. :B

Travelon
2004 Silverado 2500HD D/A CC LB 4x4, Timbrens, Fold-a-Cover,
Line-X, DeeZee Running Boards, Prodigy, Husky 16K UBS,
2004 Titanium 32E37DS, Two Honda EU2000i

billtex
Explorer II
Explorer II
BMW442 wrote:
Like I said, things could have been much much worse...


How???
2020 F350 CC LB
Eagle Cap 850
25'Airstream Excella
"Good People Drink Good Beer"-Hunter S Thompson

bcbouy
Explorer
Explorer
i feel your pain. i had the drivers side front clamp for the old sun lite pop up snap off at 100 km/h.hell of a bang.i stopped right away but still bent the roof hinge a little bit.we had to ratchet clamp the roof down till i could hit a hardware store and repair it.i know how easy it is to lose the roof.now we stop regularly and check the camper and the boat when travelling.
2012 ram 2500 hemi crew cab sb 4x4 2015 northstar 850 sc 14.5 g3 guide custom fly fishing boat