SoundGuy wrote:
With the OP not telling us anything specific about the particular truck in question who's to say how capable (or not) it may be negotiating serious upgrades? :h I tow with a 5.3L Avalanche equipped with GM's ubiquitous non-tow friendly 3.42 axle ratio and because it has the older wide ratio 4-spd transmission I always tow our 4500 lb 20' travel trailer in 3rd with Tow / Haul engaged. Towing in Drive even over relatively flat terrain results in too much unintended downshifting and serious upgrades require a downshift to 2nd. Newer GM 1/2 tons that produce even more power, are coupled to a much better narrow ratio 6-speed transmission, and which are equipped with a tow friendly 3.73 axle ratio would do much better. Bottom line - no one can answer the OP's question with any degree of certainty unless more specific information about this particular truck is provided.
Agreed that more info should have been given. However, I am of the opinion that any 1500 series pickup should be able to pull 4,600# up any reasonable grade, including those I mentioned. Assuming of course that the truck is in good sound condition. How fast? What gear? No one can guess without more info. And of course there is the question of what the OP considers successful. I see plenty of old rigs on US395 chugging along at 1st gear speeds. Are the drivers happy? Dunno.
There is also still a portable water tank provided at the top of Sherwin, so I assume enough people have problems that maintaining it is considered worthwhile by the state. Cooling!!! Cooling is always the primary issue.